Decarbonizing aviation - is ammonia the next hydrogen?

Prashant-prabhakar

09 May 2022

The international aviation community has set a roadmap of achieving zero emissions, or at least half of what is being produced right now, by 2050. Various strides have been made to improvise current propulsion systems to make them more efficient and environment-friendly.

Illustrative | Investable Universe

Aviation stalwarts have already begun experimenting and testing the technological feasibility of various propulsion systems-hydrogen, electric and ion propulsion to name a few. Current regulations now allow airlines to fly on 50% SAF and it will just be a matter of time before we start flying on 100% SAF.

ADS Group

Aviation H2, an Australian-based company, envisions minimizing the leaning of commercial aircraft towards standard Jet-A jet fuel, by burning green ammonia instead.

New Atlas

Wait, what? Yes, you heard that right.

The second-most produced chemical in the world today, ammonia is touted to be a promising source of energy carrier and source of future fuel, with interesting potential for decarbonizing aviation, rail and shipping alike. Although primarily used as a fertilizer, it is touted to move and store green hydrogen more effectively once the clean energy revolution kicks in.

Clean, renewable energy is produced at a point which is often miles away from where the demand is and hence, transportation becomes the catch. If that clean energy is used to electrolyze water and produce hydrogen, it can be stored and transported. Or better yet, that hydrogen can also be mixed with atmospheric nitrogen to produce ammonia, which travels much better than either gaseous or cryogenic liquid H2.

Hydrogen gas is very light for the energy it holds, and liquid hydrogen is even lighter. But the tanks are big and heavy. We certainly don't discount liquid hydrogen or any other form of hydrogen as an option. We're not shutting those down. We're just going with ammonia for now. It's the simplest conversion, and that intrinsically will make it the most reliable, and that in itself makes it intrinsically the safestAviation H2 Director Christof Mayer

Helmut Mayer-brother of Christof Mayer(pictured above) | New Atlas

How is it any better and cheaper than a hydrogen fuel cell conversion?

Mayer states that with a few modifications, a regular jet engine can be converted to run on ammonia, eliminating all its carbon dioxide emissions in a way that doesn't throw the baby out with the bathwater as opposed to a hydrogen fuel cell propulsion system which would require the turbofan engines to be replaced by electric motors as well as gutting the fuel storage systems and putting in something radically different.

Aviation H2

We need to modify the fuel storage system into something that's basically similar to an LPG tank. So it's the fuel storage, the engine control, and the engine, those are the big ticket items that we need to develop. But we're not really changing the design of the engine much at all physicallysays Mayer

Illustrative | New Atlas

However, with all being said, there's still an inevitable catch. As the hydrogen in ammonia is broken off during combustion, it joins with atmospheric oxygen to form water, while a percentage of the nitrogen also gets oxidized in the flame, causing environmentally harmful nitrous oxides.

Yes, it gives off nitrous oxides. But we can control those by special processes. We don't just squirt the ammonia in there and burn, there's certain things we have to do to it, and there's certain controls we have to put in place inside the fuel control systemSays Mayer

Starting, the company plans to get a small regional nine-seat jet built and flight tested. It has, apparently, signed an agreement with charter operator FalconAir, giving Aviation H2 access to FalconAir's hangars, facilities and operating licenses. The aircraft is expected to do hour-long flights, with the same engine thrust and performance characteristics as it would get on Jet-A.

As a part of the "proof of concept" flight, the company plans to get the aircraft in the skies with at least one engine running on ammonia, by mid-2023, which, could be a first for jet-powered aviation.

Eventually, Aviation H2 hopes to begin retrofitting existing planes as a transitional step for carriers looking to decarbonize, taking advantage of the fact that the rest of the aircraft is already fully certified to bring down compliance costs.

SOURCE(s)

COVER: NBAA

Read next

Tata Projects shortlisted to build various airside and landside facilities at Noida Airport

Radhika Bansal

09 May 2022

Tata Projects has been shortlisted to construct the terminal, runway, and various other airside and landside facilities at the Noida International Airport in Jewar.

The infrastructure and construction arm of Tata group is said to have scored higher than rival bidders – Larsen & Toubro and Shapoorji Pallonji group under the quality and cost-based selection criteria that are being followed for the selection of the contractor.

ALSO READ - Work on Noida International Airport’s runway, terminal building and ATC to begin in May

Tata Projects shortlisted to build various airside and landside facilities at Noida Airport

Currently, negotiations are underway between the shortlisted bidder and Noida International Airport (NIA) and the contract award could take place after two to three weeks, a source said.

“We are still in the process of selecting an EPC contractor for the development of Noida International Airport. We will share information on the contractor once a final decision has been taken,” NIA said in a statement.

In April 2021, Noida airport invited bids for engineering, procurement, and construction of the terminal, runway, and various other works.

Tata Projects is executing critical road, rail, and metro projects in the country. It has also been selected for the construction of the new parliament building in Delhi.

In November 2021, Prime Minister Narendra Modi laid the foundation stone of Jewar.

But its experience in airport construction space is limited. In 2018 it won the contract for the construction of a new terminal building at Prayagraj airport in Uttar Pradesh and is credited for completing the project in a record 11 months.

ALSO RAED - PM Modi lays the foundation of Noida International Airport

In November 2021, Prime Minister Narendra Modi laid the foundation stone of Jewar. Spread over 1334 hectares the airport will have a single runway in phase I and will be capable of handling twelve million passengers annually. The airport is expected to get operational by 2024.

The project is being developed as a public-private partnership between Zurich Airport and Uttar Pradesh government. Zurich Airport is investing INR 5,700 crore for phase I and has tied up around INR 3,725 crore in debt from the State Bank of India for the project.

In April 2021, Noida airport invited bids for engineering, procurement, and construction of the terminal, runway, and various other works.

The airport will be strategically located at about 72 km from Indira Gandhi International Airport, Delhi; about 52 km from Noida, about 130 km from Agra and about 90 km from Multi-Modal Logistics Hub at Dadri.

ALSO READ - UP government to purchase extra 7.9 hectares of land for Noida Airport

YIAPL commenced the groundwork on the airport soon after Prime Minister Narendra Modi laid the foundation stone for this project in Nov 2021. YIAPL has so far completed the construction of 9km of the 17km-long boundary wall around 1,334 hectares of land on which the greenfield is being developed. The ground has also been completely levelled.

Read next

Mumbai Airport to levy development fees on flyers till June end

Radhika Bansal

09 May 2022

Passengers flying out of Mumbai Airport will continue paying the development fees (DF) till June 30, 2022. The Airports Economic Regulatory Authority (AERA) has extended the levy of INR 120 and INR 720 per departing domestic and international passenger, respectively, from March 31, 2022, to June end as an interim measure.

The regulator has also directed the Airports Authority of India (AAI) to "examine all issues being raised by Mumbai International Airport Ltd (MIAL)” on this subject by May 15.

AERA had in December 2012 sanctioned charging a DF of INR 100 and INR 600 per departing domestic and international passenger, respectively, till April 30, 2021, to finance a deficit of INR 3,845 crore in Chhatrapati Shivaji Maharaj International Airport (CSMIA) capacity enhancement project.

Mumbai Airport to levy development fees on flyers till June end

Subsequently, in January 2016, it allowed a levy of INR 20 and INR 120 per departing domestic and international passenger, respectively, till March 31, 2021, to finance metro works at the airport worth INR 518 crore.

These two levies were merged to become INR 120 and INR 720 per departing domestic and international passenger. When Covid hit airport footfalls severely and collection suffered badly, AERA had on MIAL’s request extended these two levies till March 31, 2022.

AAI had this March told AERA that “DF to be billed as on September 30, 2021, is INR 401.9 crore. However, as per MIAL, DF billable (on that date) is INR 1459 crore. Further (AAI informed) MDF (metro DF) to be billed by MIAL as of September 30, 2021, is INR 89.6 crore.

“A further request was received from MIAL for extension of the period of levy… due to shortfall in the collection… beyond March 31, 2022, on an interim basis. A letter was sent to AAI on January 25, 2022, for (its) comments regarding year-wise DF collected from passengers, amount disbursed to MIAL, interest payment, details of utilisation…MIAL had claimed outstanding MDF as of September 30, 2021, as INR 106.8 crore. In addition, AAI has pointed out certain issues of importance in the DF and MDF audit reports and MIAL’s claim, which needs to be sorted out."AERA order dated March 28, 2022

“In view of paucity of time for resolving the issues and reconciliation of figures,” the order says “there is a necessity to extend the levy of DF beyond March 2022, to recover the sanctioned DF amount.

Accordingly, it is decided to extend the levy of DF up to June 30, 2022. In the meantime, the position will be examined and further action/Order will be issued based on such examination.”

AERA has directed AAI to examine all issues raised by MIAL by May 15 and also asked the airport operator to “provide all required documents to AAI in this regard.”

Read next

Jet Airways 2.0 gets security clearance from Home Ministry

Radhika Bansal

09 May 2022

The Union Home Ministry has granted security clearance to Jet Airways which is planning to relaunch commercial flight operations in the next few months, according to an official document. The letter was also sent to aviation safety regulator DGCA and aviation security regulator BCAS.

The Jalan-Kalrock Consortium is currently the promoter of Jet Airways. The airline in its old avatar was owned by Naresh Goyal and had operated its last flight on April 17, 2019.

ALSO READ - Jet Airways conducts test flight after more than 3 years

Last Thursday, May 5, the airline conducted its test flight to and from the Hyderabad airport in a step towards obtaining the air operator certificate.

Jet Airways 2.0 gets security clearance from Home Ministry

A letter sent by the civil aviation ministry to the airline on May 6 informed it about the grant of the security clearance by the Union home ministry. 

The letter said, it is "directed to refer to your application… to convey security clearance for change in shareholding pattern of the company/firm, for scheduled operator permit, based on security clearance received from the Ministry of Home Affairs".

"The security clearance can, however, be withdrawn any time in the light of any adverse inputs, if so received from the Ministry of Home Affairs in future," it added.

On May 5, the airline conducted its test flight to and from the Hyderabad airport in a step towards obtaining the air operator certificate.

Last Thursday's test flight was conducted to prove to aviation regulator DGCA that the aircraft and its components are operating normally.

ALSO READ - Jet Airways returning with a hybrid premium and no-frills model, first flight likely by October 2022

After the test flight, the airline has to conduct proving flights after which the Directorate General of Civil Aviation (DGCA) will grant the air operator certificate. Proving flights are similar to commercial flights with DGCA officials and airline officials as passengers and cabin crew members on board.

ALSO READ - Sanjiv Kapoor named as the CEO of Jet Airways

Jet Airways’ flying licence or AOP was made dormant, months after it stopped flying.

Last month, the airline appointed industry veteran Sanjiv Kapoor, former chief strategy and commercial officer at Vistara, as its CEO.

Jet Airways already has more than 150 employees on its rolls and the airline is also speaking to vendors, including lessors, for the relaunch.

Jet Airways stopped operating in April 2019, burdened under piling losses, debt and dues. Jet Airways’ flying licence or AOP was made dormant, months after it stopped flying.

Read next

IndiGo plans to make behavioural testing a requirement for pilot upgrade and promotion

Radhika Bansal

09 May 2022

IndiGo, India's largest airline, will require pilots to participate in Behavioural Event Interviews in order to be upgraded and promoted to management positions.

According to an internal memo reviewed by Business Standard, Behavioral Assessment Interviews (BEI) will be required for all management positions in the flight operations department, including Fleet Supervisors, trainers, and auditors, as well as for pilots seeking upgrades as captains from senior first officers.

IndiGo has collaborated with human resource consulting firm Aon Hewitt to create the programme, which will make BEI mandatory for upgrades and leadership positions.

IndiGo plans to make behavioural testing a requirement for pilot upgrade and promotion

The inclusion of BEI as part of upgrade and promotion comes in the backdrop of pilot unrest in the company, due to a delay in restoration of salary cuts which were induced in phase during two years of the pandemic.

The airline suspended five pilots—in what is the first cause of action against organised labour protest the airline witnessed in its inception.

“The attitude of its employees plays a pivotal role in shaping an organization. With our focus being on enhancing and shaping the right attitude for Pilots, inside and outside the cockpit, we move towards our next critical step in the Pilot Upgrade Project. I am confident that these behavioral interviews will help us choose and upgrade the right people for the right job which is a much required necessity for any organization to become world class,” Ashim Mittra, Senior Vice President, Flight Operations, IndiGo

In human resources terms, the objective of a BEI is to get very detailed behavioural descriptions of how a person will react under different conditions. In aviation, it is a crucial part of crew resource management, to choose the best-aligned candidates for the company and mitigate the future risks of pilot conflicts.

An IndiGo spokesperson said that while the BEI interviews will currently be rolled out for the flight operations department, gauging the impact and outcome of the same, it can be implemented across the departments.

A senior executive of the airline said that during the interview if a person fails, he will be handled and counselled by experts for six months after which he can reappear for the interview.

IndiGo has collaborated with human resource consulting firm Aon Hewitt to create the programme, which will make BEI mandatory for upgrades and leadership positions.

Inclusion of BEI is part of our long term plan to help align our Pilots to the company’s culture and values by selecting the right attitude and the right behaviour for the right work profile. It will identify and upgrade those pilots who are already aligned and guide those who need to be moulded and polished,” the executive said adding that while currently BEI will be used for upgrades & management positions it will soon be launched for newly inducted pilots too.

“We need to identify leadership competencies in our pilots which are aligned to the core values of IndiGo and give our customers an enhanced experience of on-time, hassle-free and courteous experience from the flight deck,” he said.

The airline has also begun a new process for newly hired pilots called "culture training," in which they will spend time with other flight operations departments such as rostering and scheduling to get used to their new jobs.

The airline has also begun a new process for newly hired pilots called "culture training"

Pilot pay has become a thorny issue for India's largest airline, with pilots dissatisfied that their pre-Covid pay has not yet been fully restored.

Despite a partial salary increase, pilots are still disgruntled because the airline is now operating over 1,600 flights per day, which is higher than before COVID grounded travel.

However, senior executives of the airline pointed out that the number of flights is not an indicator that the airline has regained its financial health and utilisation of aircraft still remains low with high fuel prices increasing the cost of operations manifold.

ALSO READ - IndiGo pilots investigated for using obscene language on emergency radio frequency

A few unhappy pilots expressing unhappiness over salary cuts even used expletives on the radio while operating aircraft, prompting an investigation by civil aviation regulator DGCA.

(With Inputs from Business Standard)

Read next

Potential software malfunction detected in Airbus A350 - EASA springs into action, issues emergency AD

Prashant-prabhakar

08 May 2022

In what could be a recipe for disaster, a potentially critical issue has been detected on the Airbus A350-900 and -1000, which could possibly render the pilots helpless in controlling the stability of the aircraft.

Twitter

Reportedly, a software bug has been detected on the Airbus A350 which could potentially lead to a loss of elevator control-one of the worst control to be lost.

An elevator is a primary flight control surface that controls movement about the lateral axis of an aircraft-a movement referred to as "pitch".

Illustrative | Tekno-Port

Therefore, a directive was issued on May 5th and is tentatively expected to go effective from the 9th of May. Apparently, the European Union Aviation Safety Agency (EASA) has asked operators of the Airbus A350-900 and -1000 to amend the applicable AFM (airplane flight manual) and Minimum Equipment List accordingly.

An occurrence was reported where the PRIMary flight control computers (PRIMs) indicated that both elevator actuators were considered faulty." The airworthiness directive (AD) also states that subsequent investigations had found that incorrect instructions had been implemented with the introduction of the "PRIM P13 standard", which is part of the Flight Control and Guidance System (FCGS) X13 standardPublished as Emergency Airworthiness Directive 2022-0079-E, EASA

Furthermore, the Airworthiness Directive also stated that subsequent investigations pointed to incorrect instructions being implemented with the introduction of the "PRIM P13 standard"- which also happens to be a part of the Flight Control and Guidance System (FCGS) X13 standard.

Source

The emergency AD by EASA could mean further ADs could possibly follow in the days to come. EASA has set the deadline to MAY 16 within which it expects operators to amend the AFM with a temporary revision (TR), noted as AFM TR 132 issue 1 or 133 issues 1.

Inform all flight crews, and, thereafter, operate the aeroplane accordinglyEASA's directive stated

Now one might ask, how could a simple "amendment" possibly fix a loss of elevator control?

Reportedly, it is only a software bug "indicating" a malfunction, and there perhaps, might not be an "actual" loss of control of the elevator. In simple words, the bug in itself might not cause issues but the human actions resulting from following that definitely might.

SOURCE(s)

COVER: Aviation Week

Comment