Experts disagree on the noise rules for supersonic jet reintroduction

Radhika Bansal

08 Feb 2022

Environmentalists and some European nations are set to clash with the United States over a possible comeback of supersonic travel, saying efforts to set noise guidelines by the middle of the decade could weaken efforts to fight climate change.

Nearly two decades after the last flight of the Anglo-French Concorde, a panel of United Nations aviation experts is meeting from Monday, February 7 and will consider updating a decades-old supersonic noise standard by 2025, according to meeting papers seen by Reuters.

Anglo-French Concorde's last commercial flight was in October 2003.

The U.S.-backed push by aerospace companies is supported by the U.S.-based Boom, which has vowed to launch a quieter and less polluting form of supersonic travel than the sleek but noisy Concorde, which ferried the rich and famous across the Atlantic.

Even though it co-developed the only commercial jet to break the sound barrier in the 1960s, France has teamed up with Norway and Sweden to try to delay procedural work on future supersonic jetliners to focus on emissions rules for subsonic flight.

All three countries have made climate action a political priority and want U.N. experts to focus on the source of the current industry emissions, people close to the International Civil Aviation Organization discussions said.

Montreal-based ICAO sets standards on everything from runway markings to crash investigations, which its 193 member states typically translate into regulatory requirements.

Planemakers need those standards "well in advance" to ensure they meet official expectations, said Dan Carnelly, vice-president at the International Coordinating Council of Aerospace Industries Associations, an international aerospace lobby.

"No manufacturer can take the risk that they invest billions of dollars to design and test a new product only for it to become obsolete due to a new regulation imposed soon after it enters into service," he said.

Boom plans a North Carolina plant and has orders from United Airlines.

The very technical discussion is key for a niche market promising to create thousands of jobs. Boom plans a North Carolina plant and has orders from United Airlines.

But critics say focusing on supersonics now would divert time and expertise that could be put toward reducing broader emissions from aviation, a priority this year for ICAO's full membership, including the United States.

"Supersonic aircraft are a huge distraction for ICAO," said Dan Rutherford, aviation director at the International Council on Clean Transportation, a U.S.-based environmental research group.

Aerospace companies warn that ignoring supersonics at this early stage could be a recipe for countries to go it alone. "A patchwork of local, different regulations would be very difficult, if not impossible, to manage," Carnelly said.

ICAO declined to comment while discussions at its Committee on Aviation Environmental Protection run from Feb. 7 to 18. The U.S. Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) declined to comment. Supersonics have struggled to meet the noise and emissions standards set for conventional planes.

Boom says its 'Overture' jet would meet noise levels that already apply to subsonic planes and run fully on sustainable aviation fuel when it starts flying passengers in 2029.

Boom says its 'Overture' jet would meet noise levels that already apply to subsonic planes.

Carnelly said guidelines specifying that noise limits should be the same for supersonics and subsonic are needed for technical reasons. "The best thing for the industry is to have clear, timely and global standards," a Boom spokesperson said.

The company aims to start certification flight tests in 2026 ahead of commercial flights before the end of the decade. Some analysts remain cautious over its schedule, which originally called for the plane to enter service in 2023.

Drawbacks of Supersonic Jet

Supersonic airliners have been the objects of numerous recent and ongoing design studies. Drawbacks and design challenges are excessive noise generation (at takeoff and due to sonic booms during flight), high development costs, expensive construction materials, high fuel consumption, extremely high emissions, and an increased cost per seat over subsonic airliners. Despite these challenges, Concorde was claimed to operate profitably.

Supersonic airliners have been the objects of numerous recent and ongoing design studies.

Sonic booms aren’t just loud; they can also cause physical damage, breaking glass, cracking plaster, and shaking objects off shelves. A boom from a single fighter aircraft in 1966 dislodged tons of rock, crushing archaeological sites in the famous Canyon de Chelly National Monument.

Booms in other countries have caused cattle to stampede and even caused a roof to collapse, killing three French workers. Currently, the primary culprits are military aircraft. Some militaries eventually developed a procedure for sonic boom damage reimbursement.

(With Inputs from Reuters)

Read next

Newly constructed arrival terminal at Delhi Airport's T1, set to open soon

Radhika Bansal

08 Feb 2022

Delhi airport operator DIAL on Monday, February 7 said it has completed the expansion work of the arrival terminal at T1 and is ready for operations.

The work has been done as part of expansion plans and once complete, the airport's total terminal capacity and airside capacity will increase to 100 million and 140 million, respectively.

"DIAL has successfully completed expansion work of arrival terminal at T1 and is ready for operations… this new arrival terminal is another step towards enhancing the infrastructure and passenger experience at Delhi airport. The current domestic arrival operations will now move to the newly constructed arrival terminal, which would enable DIAL to take up the demolition of the existing arrival terminal, T1C."I Prabhakara Rao, Deputy Managing Director, GMR Group (DIAL)

Currently, Indira Gandhi International Airport's (IGIA) terminal capacity is 60 million and the airside is 100 million. The airport has three operational terminals -- T1, T2 and T3.

According to him, the building was the need of the hour and will help in enhancing the airport's operational efficiency. At present, IndiGo and SpiceJet have their domestic operations from T1.

https://twitter.com/DelhiAirport/status/1490625166971338755

"Upon completion, the new Terminal 1 would have integrated arrival and departure terminals, a new node building housing retail and F&B outlets, and a pier building comprising 22 contact stands," the release said.

The new arrival terminal at T1 has a huge space between baggage belts for ease of movement and a state-of-the-art meet and greet gallery, among other facilities, the release said, adding that the terminal will offer a distinctive experience to flyers.

"Expansion projects under Phase 3A will help Delhi airport to become future-ready, as Delhi airport's terminal capacity will increase to 100 million passengers per annum (MPPA) while airside capacity will rise to 140 MPPA," the release said.

As part of the overall development plan under Phase 3A, DIAL will construct the airport's fourth runway, dual elevated Eastern Cross Taxiways (ECT) to connect the northern and southern airfields, landside developments for circulation and connectivity improvements and T3 modification works, among others.

Read next

Safety at 30,000ft in the air - What's trending in aviation HUDs and how do they work?

Prashant-prabhakar

08 Feb 2022

If you are a fan of air combat movies and combat moves depicted in them, then you're most familiar with the transparent display(s) depicted, that gives a pilot a seamless view of critical flight information, projected directly in the pilot's line of sight.

These displays are termed as HUD, or Heads-Up-Display and have been used for decades by military pilots and have now become fairly commonplace in both large commercial aircraft and private planes.

Flickr

The technology derives its name from the fact that pilots now don't have to look down at their instruments and take their eyes off the surrounding environment while allowing them to focus their attention outside the cockpit for ­potential conflicts or threats.

Also referred to as enhanced flight vision systems (or EFVS), they can be of significant importance, especially during the critical phases of flight- landing and take-off.

HUD guidance has been known to reduce tail strikes on takeoff. Studies conducted by the Flight Safety Foundation have shown that about 38% of commercial, business, and corporate airplane accidents could have been prevented using HUD systems, over 13 years.

HUDs help pilots during takeoff and landing in uncertain environmental conditions such as foggy weather. Moreover, most aviation administrations around the world have mandates on the use of enhanced flight vision systems to reduce accidents and increase passenger safety. As the aviation industry has in the past accounted for a major share of the HUD market, an increase in the orders for new-generation aircraft will also drive the growth of the HUD marketSource

How do they work?

Technically, a HUD projector sends critical to flight, navigation and aircraft energy-management data to a glass screen, called a combiner, hanging at eye level between the pilot and the windshield.

The concave-shaped combiner glass is coated with a proprietary ­material that reflects the colour green but allows everything else, such as the scenery outside, to pass through, appearing quite naturally. The coating reflects green to illuminate the HUD’s symbology and this is because the human eye is most sensitive to that colour.

However, though, not all HUDs are created equal. One difference relates to the field of view hence aviation HUDs are designed so that flight information appears to be on the same visual plane as objects in the environment. This ensures pilots don’t need to refocus their eyes when looking back and forth between projections on the screen and the exterior environment.

FAA regulations require at least the following aspects to be displayed at all times:

AirspeedAltitudeHeadingHorizon lineTurb and slip/turn and bank indicator

Then Vs Now

Rudimentary HUDs were first developed for World War II aircraft and became widely used in military applications during the 1960s. The first civil application of the technology was introduced in 1993.

Vintage HUD | Representative | Aviation Today

Conventional HUDs display virtual shapes and symbols that provide weather, navigational, and other information, collectively referred to as "symbology"- a collective term for aircraft position, altitude, a horizon line, heading & flight path, radar data, and airspeed, along with other data from the plane's avionics and instrumentation.

The Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) now allows pilots to make landings in “no natural vision” (zero-visibility) situations as long as there is an aircraft HUD system or a helmet-mounted display (HMD) for the pilot.

BAE Systems Digital Striker Helmet-Mounted Display (HMD) System with Superior Tracking and Night Vision Capabilities | Business Wire

What's trending in aviation HUDs as of today

Increased Display area : The Boeing 787 dreamliner features two HUD display panels, one for the pilot and co-pilot respectively, Designed by Rockwell Collins, this is more than double the size of the display area as on the 777.

A Boeing 787 HUD | Reddit

Digital HUD displays : Aviation has come a long way from CRT displays to the more developed digital displays now. For instance, the US Air Force's F-22 Raptor features an all-digital HUD which removes the CRT image source and instead uses Digital Light Engine (DLE) technology to implement a more advanced HUD that is placed immediately in front of the pilot’s line of sight.

Digital Light Engine technology to illuminate F-22 Head-Up Display | baesystems

Synthetic and Enhanced Vision : Synthetic vision refers to the use of algorithms to generate 3D images of the environment whereas Enhanced vision systems incorporate information from various sensors on the aircraft (near-infrared cameras, millimeter wave radar) to provide more information to pilots in limited visibility environments. Millenium jets today, now feature HUDs which integrate both-synthetic and enhanced vision into one, like the ones featured on Embraer's Praetor jets.

Praetor 500 and Praetor 600 cockpit | Representative | Skies Magazine

With the development of holographic optics and Augmented-Virtual Reality, it might not be far when they shall also be integrated into aviation HUDs soon enough.

Across both the automotive and aviation sectors, right now the design of large field-of-view head-up displays – which are increasingly required for augmented reality applications – is limited by the necessarily large size of the optical componentsA research engineer from Thales explains

Quality standards and regulations

Owing to their critical significance in real-time flight situations, they need to adhere to several Advisory Circulars released by the FAA, some of which include:

1 AC-25-11B- Electronic Flight Displays

2. AC-90-106A- Enhanced Flight Vision Systems

3. AC-25_1329-1C- Approval of Flight Guidance Systems

4. AC-20-167A- Airworthiness Approval of Enhanced Vision System, Synthetic Vision System, Combined Vision System, and Enhanced Flight Vision System Equipment.

Rockwell Collins’ new EVS-3000 delivers unprecedented accuracy of outside terrain, hazards and obstacles in low-visibility conditions | Rotornation

The benefits of aircraft HUD systems cannot be understated and it is these advantages that have made the commercial aviation industry a key driver of growth in the HUD market - which is projected to reach USD 2.18 billion by 2024.

SOURCE(s)

COVER: Premium Wall Art

Read next

Boeing 777X to be displayed at the Singapore Airshow 2022; will highlight sustainability, technology, and partnerships

Radhika Bansal

08 Feb 2022

At the Singapore Airshow this month, the largest in Southeast Asia, Boeing will showcase its industry-leading portfolio of commercial, defence and support services by highlighting advanced systems and capabilities focused on safe and sustainable aerospace.

Boeing's presence at the show will include its newest fuel-efficient widebody jet, the 777X, along with the company's offerings in maritime patrol aircraft, advanced fighters and trainers, and autonomous systems.

"We are looking forward to gathering with our industry colleagues in Singapore, in support of the recovery of aviation in the Southeast Asia region, as it provides us an opportunity to engage with customers, government officials, partners, suppliers, media and other stakeholders from the region. We will highlight our investment in, and commitment to, technology, innovation and sustainability, building the foundation for the long-term growth of the aerospace industry."Alex Feldman, President, Boeing Southeast Asia

During the show, a Boeing 777X flight test airplane will make its Asia debut, demonstrating aerial manoeuvres that showcase its new carbon-fibre composite wing and quiet GE9X engines, which contribute to the airplane family's leading environmental performance.

Based on the most successful twin-aisle airplane ever, the 777, and with advanced technologies from the 787 Dreamliner family, the 777-9 will be the world's largest and most efficient twin-engine jet, delivering 10% better fuel use, emissions and operating costs than the competition.

https://twitter.com/Boeing/status/1490528325898575873

Boeing's exhibit at the show will also highlight the F-15, P-8 Poseidon, T-7A Advanced Pilot Training System, as well as autonomous technology including the Boeing Airpower Teaming System, which is the company's first uncrewed system to be designed and developed in Australia.

Designed to provide a transformational capability for global defence customers, it is the company's largest investment in a new uncrewed aircraft program outside the United States. This purpose-built aircraft can be missionized to suit country-specific needs.

The United States Department of Defense corral is expected to display the KC-46A Pegasus, P-8A Poseidon, and C-17 Globemaster III.

The United States Department of Defense corral is expected to display the KC-46A Pegasus.

Additionally, Boeing will highlight its growing digital ecosystem of services, including integrated flight operations, a data-driven supply chain, e-commerce, predictive maintenance, digitally-enabled MROs and competency-based training for commercial and defence customers.

Showcased service offerings use digital innovation to reduce fuel use and support sustainability targets for customers utilizing all airplane platforms.

Boeing will also focus on measures to deliver a safer, more efficient and sustainable air transportation system for the future with an emphasis on the Confident Travel Initiative, a Boeing led effort to provide passengers and crew with a safe, healthy and efficient travel experience and deliver that information to governments and the general public.

Boeing 777X will be on display at the Singapore Airshow 2022

The Boeing 777X made its first test flight over two years ago, with the company at the time projecting the first 777X deliveries to take place in 2021. The latest estimates have the aircraft entering service within the next two years, with Boeing CEO Dave Calhoun aiming for Q4 2023.

Boeing's late-2023 entry date for the 777X appears increasingly unrealistic. In June 2021, the FAA revealed that certification for the 777X is unlikely to happen until early-to-mid 2023, putting a late-2023 entry date in serious doubt.

Read next

Bahrain International Airport receives a 5-star rating from Skytrax

Radhika Bansal

08 Feb 2022

Bahrain International Airport (BIA) has received a five-star rating from the airline and airport rating body Skytrax, which was announced on Sunday, February 6.

The rating includes direct services for departures, arrivals, and diverted flights, including airport facilities and customer services, security, immigration, and retail, as well as food and beverage facilities.

“This international-level achievement by BIA owes a lot to His Majesty, King Hamad bin Isa Al Khalifa’s support for the aviation sector and the full backing of the government, headed by His Royal Highness Prince Salman bin Hamad Al Khalifa, the Crown Prince and Prime Minister. This sector is a pillar of the Kingdom’s economic growth and a major focus of its development plan for the logistics sector.”Kamal bin Ahmed Mohammed, Minister of transportation and telecommunications and Chairman, Bahrain Airport Company (BAC)

Located on a small island north of the capital Manama, Bahrain International Airport is the main gateway to the city of the Kingdom of Bahrain. The airport hosts passenger and cargo traffic from over 30 carriers. 

“It is a great achievement for Bahrain International Airport to become just the third airport in the Middle East to achieve this highest 5-Star Airport Rating. It is a much-deserved recognition of the high standards provided at BIA. Described as a boutique airport, it provides an excellent range of passenger facilities with a very pleasant ambience, and the terminal design makes this a most customer-friendly airport, whether departing, arriving, or in transit.”Edward Plaisted, CEO, Skytrax

Bahrain International Airport is the main hub for Gulf Air. The airport is managed and operated by the Bahrain Airport Company since 2010.

The airport caters to a growing number of airlines and serves as the regional hub for global cargo companies, including DHL, which has made Bahrain as their base to serve the Middle East since the 1980s.

Operations were transferred to the new Passenger Terminal in January 2021, increasing the airport capacity to 14 million passengers per year and cementing its reputation as an attractive hub for airlines and travellers.

Read next

Rourkela Airport's expansion plan hampered by slow progress

Radhika Bansal

08 Feb 2022

The tardy pace of work on the new apron and taxiway of Rourkela airport has raised apprehensions about whether the facility can be made operational before the Men’s Hockey World Cup in January 2023. 

While the Airports Authority of India (AAI) has been accused of deliberately limiting the runway length to operate only smaller aircraft from the airport, a tender of INR 5.69 crore for construction of the new apron and taxiway was awarded to Ranchi-based RK Mishra and Co in June 2021.

Rourkela Airport's expansion plan was hampered by slow progress.

It took the firm seven months to fill the earth. This apart, the cementing of the taxiway started only recently. It is unclear when work would start for the proposed terminal building to accommodate 200 passengers.    

What is more worrying is the present runway length is getting extended to around 6,330 feet (1,930 metres) to cater only to ATR-72 and it would not allow bigger aircraft like Boeing and Airbus to operate from the airport. 

This is even though the Rourkela Steel Plant (RSP) has provided an additional 146 acres using which the runway could be expanded to over 7,500 feet to operate big body aircraft like A320, A320 Neo and A321 Neo.  

The present runway of 5,655 feet (1,724 metres) is adequate to cater to ATR 72-600.

Aviation enthusiasts said the present runway of 5,655 feet (1,724 metres) is adequate to cater to ATR 72-600 and De Havilland 8-400 aircraft but three years back the airport was granted ARC 2B licence for 19-seater as such smaller aircraft was not available. 

Sources said around 1,349 feet of the existing serviceable runway is being discarded over reasons unknown. The AAI  has also downgraded its plan to apply for an ARC 2C licence from ARC 3C. 

Rourkela Development Steering Committee chairman and former president of Rourkela Chamber of Commerce & Industry (RCCI) Subrata Patnaik claimed the AAI is deliberately limiting the runway length to 6,330 feet, fearing that after the mega hockey event the airport may be closed to promote the Jharsuguda airport. 

Patnaik apprehended if commercial flights are not started from the airport before the event,  it will be an embarrassment for Odisha. 

Earlier, the AAI had hoped to complete the upgradation of the airport by March 2022, apply for replacing the ARC 2B licence with ARC 2C licence in May and start operation of ATR-72 from October. But, now it looks like a remote possibility. 

After a joint meeting with top Civil Aviation officials on February 15, 2021, at Rourkela, the then Transport and Commerce department Principal Secretary MS Padhi had hoped to complete upgradation works by September and start commercial flights from December 2021. 

The airport is mostly used by dignitaries visiting Rourkela, especially officials of Steel Authority of India Limited (SAIL) and other VIPs.

To expedite the works, the AAI had recently posted three officers at Rourkela. The Chief Minister’s Office is scheduled to review the progress of the airport with AAI officials on February 11.

Rourkela Airport, Airport Code - RRK, is a domestic airport located near Chhend Colony, 6 kilometres west of the steel city of Rourkela in the state of Odisha. The airport is mostly used by dignitaries visiting Rourkela, especially officials of Steel Authority of India Limited (SAIL) and other VIPs.

The airport's terminal is being upgraded to handle scheduled operations. Under the UDAN scheme, scheduled flights were to start but this has not materialized. A license for commercial usage of the airport was issued in January 2019.

Comment