Is Air India’s New Room-Sharing Policy for Cabin Crew a Step Too Far?
Abhishek Nayar
29 Oct 2024
In a move that has sparked controversy and resistance, Tata Group-owned Air India recently announced a new room-sharing policy for its cabin crew, which will take effect on December 1. The All-India Cabin Crew Association (AICCA), a 50-year-old trade union, has condemned the policy, calling it "illegal, bad in law, and void ab initio on multiple fronts." The association has requested intervention from India’s Labor Ministry to halt the implementation, citing the potential violation of previous agreements, industrial regulations, and tribunal decisions.
Understanding the Room-Sharing Policy
Air India’s new policy mandates that cabin crew members share rooms during layovers, except for cabin executives and crew on ultra-long-haul flights. This change has stirred concerns and criticisms from AICCA, who claim that the policy contradicts the standing agreements, tribunal awards, and industry standards.
Under this policy:
- Cabin executives and crew on ultra-long-haul flights will continue to receive single rooms.
- All other cabin crew members will be required to share rooms on layovers, a move justified by Air India ahead of its upcoming merger with Vistara, set for November 11.
- Ultra-long-haul flights are defined as those lasting 16 hours or more, such as Air India’s flights to North America. In cases of unscheduled layovers due to flight diversions, crew members on these flights will also be entitled to single rooms.
With a combined workforce of 25,000 employee’s post-merger, including approximately 12,000 cabin crew members, this policy is seen as an attempt to optimize operational costs. However, it has faced fierce opposition from the AICCA, which represents cabin crew members across various Indian and foreign airlines.
Opposition from the All-India Cabin Crew Association
The AICCA has called the new policy "draconian" and has requested the immediate assistance of the Chief Labor Commissioner (CLC) to stay the policy’s implementation. The association claims that the decision is unilateral, changing the service conditions of cabin crew members while an industrial dispute over the matter is still pending in the National Industrial Tribunal.
In a notice addressed to the CLC in New Delhi, the AICCA argued:
"This is an illegal move and also a change in conditions of service under the IESO— (Industrial Employees Standing Orders Act), under which the establishment is bound, other than during the pendency of the NIT and Industrial Dispute."
The association further asserts that similar attempts to implement such a policy were made in 2018 by Air India’s previous management and the Ministry of Civil Aviation. These efforts were resisted by the AICCA on "legal, ethical, and moral grounds."
Global Standards and Regulatory Concerns
The AICCA argues that Air India’s room-sharing policy violates international standards set by global regulatory bodies, including the U.S. Federal Aviation Administration (FAA), European Aviation Safety Agency (EASA), and the International Civil Aviation Organization (ICAO). According to AICCA, such regulatory bodies require appropriate accommodation for crew members to ensure adequate rest, which is essential for maintaining safety and well-being on duty.
Furthermore, the AICCA’s complaint to Air India CEO Campbell Wilson highlighted the alleged breach of the Industrial Disputes Act, stressing that the policy violates Section 33-C. This section stipulates that no service conditions can be altered during the pendency of an industrial dispute. The association has warned of possible prosecution of Air India officers if the policy is enforced, citing a breach of industrial law.
Appeals for Dialogue and Ethical Conduct
In its notice to Campbell Wilson, the AICCA has urged Air India to maintain the current status quo, respect the ongoing proceedings of the National Industrial Tribunal, and engage in constructive dialogue. The association expressed hopes for “mutual interests for the larger benefit” of Air India and its cabin crew members, calling for a balanced solution that does not compromise the crew’s well-being or rights.
What’s Next for Air India?
As the December 1 implementation date approaches, the AICCA is lobbying intensely to prevent what it perceives as a setback for cabin crew welfare and safety standards. It remains to be seen whether the Labor Ministry will intervene or if Air India will reconsider its stance amid mounting pressure. For now, the association is determined to hold the airline accountable to existing agreements and industry practices, advocating for single-room accommodation in line with pilot standards and industry norms.
Conclusion
Air India’s new room-sharing policy for cabin crew has sparked a heated debate on workers' rights, regulatory standards, and corporate policy within the aviation industry. While the airline argues that the policy is essential for streamlining operations amid a large-scale merger, the AICCA remains firm that crew welfare and service conditions should not be compromised. As stakeholders and government bodies consider their next steps, the outcome will likely set a precedent for labor standards and policy-making in the Indian aviation sector.
Read next
IndiGo Faces Turbulence Amid Fleet Grounding, High Costs: What's Next for India’s Largest Airline?
Abhishek Nayar
28 Oct 2024
India's leading budget airline, IndiGo, has hit unexpected turbulence, recording its first quarterly loss in two years. Despite its steady dominance over the Indian aviation market, a mix of fleet grounding issues, rising operational expenses, and significant changes to its service model are reshaping IndiGo’s path forward.
IndiGo’s First Loss in Two Years: What Happened?
For the quarter ending September 30, IndiGo reported a substantial loss of 9.89 billion rupees (around $117.7 million). This setback contrasts sharply with a profit of 1.88 billion rupees recorded during the same period last year. Fuel expenses, maintenance costs, and additional rentals for leased aircraft significantly contributed to the carrier’s losses. Gaurav Negi, IndiGo’s Chief Financial Officer, attributed much of the financial strain to “grounded fleet-related costs,” with the airline’s grounded planes and operational delays impacting revenue generation.
Grounded Fleet and Costly Aircraft Maintenance
IndiGo’s fleet of 410 aircraft typically makes it one of Asia's largest carriers, but engine issues, particularly with engines from supplier Pratt & Whitney, grounded over 70 planes by November last year. This grounding spurred IndiGo to extend leases on older planes and invest in newer models, adding substantial costs. Negi explained that IndiGo expects the grounded fleet to decline gradually from “high-60s currently to under 60 by the end of 2024,” with hopes to bring this number down to the 40s by April 2025. However, supplementary rentals and maintenance costs jumped by almost 30%, adding to the financial burden.
Fuel and Maintenance Costs Hit All-Time High
Rising fuel costs continued to drain IndiGo’s finances, with a 13% increase in fuel expenses. In addition, newer aircraft and engine rentals led to a four-fold rise in associated costs, indicating the high expense of IndiGo's fleet expansion and lease extension strategy. In total, expenses for the September quarter rose 22%, outpacing a 13.6% revenue increase.
Expansion Amid Setbacks: IndiGo’s High Ambitions
Despite its financial strain, IndiGo remains steadfast in its growth ambitions, aiming to expand capacity as measured by available seat kilometers in the third quarter. India, which has become the world’s fastest-growing aviation market over the past two years, is laying down ambitious goals to become a global aviation hub. IndiGo, with a significant 63% market share in India, is positioning itself to benefit from this growth. In line with the trend, IndiGo recently placed record-breaking jet orders to further expand its fleet and strengthen its capacity to match the anticipated demand in both domestic and international travel.
Big Changes: IndiGo Braces for a New Business Class
In a major shift from its all-economy cabin model, IndiGo is preparing to introduce its first-ever business class service next month on select domestic routes. This is a strategic move to attract premium domestic travelers and cater to a segment seeking additional comfort, signaling IndiGo's shift from a purely low-cost model.
A Bumpy Road Ahead or a Smooth Landing?
IndiGo’s resilience will depend on how well it navigates these challenges, particularly in managing grounded fleet costs and rising expenses. While the airline's plans for growth and diversification are bold, financial hurdles will likely test its adaptability in the coming quarters. As India’s aviation market continues to expand, IndiGo's ability to address these operational and cost-related challenges will determine whether it can continue to soar as Asia’s most valuable airline or if it will face more turbulence along the way.
With Inputs from Reuters
Read next
Will Boeing’s Ongoing Worker Strike Stall the Aerospace Industry?
Abhishek Nayar
28 Oct 2024
The recent strike by more than 33,000 Boeing factory workers has generated ripples through the aerospace industry, extending beyond the company's Washington and South Carolina plants to suppliers nationwide. Small and large businesses alike are wrestling with declining orders and potential layoffs, testing the resilience of Boeing’s supply chain. If the strike endures, its impact could escalate from temporary cutbacks to a full-scale disruption of Boeing’s production flow.
The Impact on Small Suppliers: Independent Forge’s Struggle to Survive
Independent Forge, a family-operated aerospace parts manufacturer based in Orange County, California, stands as one of the many Boeing suppliers affected. Specializing in aluminum components essential to Boeing’s commercial jets, Independent Forge has already scaled back its workforce to just 22 essential workers. President Andrew Flores shared that his company may be forced to cut operations from five to three days per week to remain afloat.
"They are the backbone of our shop. Their knowledge, I can't replace that," said Flores, emphasizing the irreplaceable skill set of his remaining team.
Supplier Workforce in Jeopardy as Demand Wanes
This predicament is not isolated. Suppliers across the country are feeling the squeeze. The Seattle-based Pathfinder, which employs young recruits in hands-on training alongside its skilled workforce, is considering additional layoffs after already reducing its staff by one-quarter in the past month. The labor strike’s continuation is compelling Pathfinder CEO Dave Trader to contemplate returning aerospace students to their high schools instead of training them on-site.
Pathfinder’s plight is mirrored by the broader supplier network. About 60% of the 2.21 million Americans in the aerospace sector work within the supply chain, making staffing cuts a potential threat to long-term production capacity. A prolonged strike could result in cascading challenges as Boeing’s suppliers brace for an extended shutdown and potential loss of expertise that may be challenging to recover.
Boeing’s Suppliers Brace for Tough Decisions
As Boeing grapples with union negotiations, suppliers are evaluating measures to cope with decreasing revenue. Five Boeing suppliers interviewed this week revealed that many would face extreme steps—furloughs, freezing investment, or even halting production—if the strike persists. Spirit AeroSystems, Boeing's significant supplier, recently furloughed 700 workers on its 767 and 777 programs for 21 days. Should the strike last beyond November, layoffs could become inevitable.
Moreover, these staffing decisions could reverberate back to Boeing, which relies on its vast supplier base for parts essential to building the 737 MAX and other commercial aircraft. Analyst Rob Stallard of Vertical Research Partners noted that starting the supply chain back up after a prolonged stall is no simple task, stating that the longer Boeing's factories remain idle, the harder it will be to restart operations at the desired production rate.
FAA Oversight and Production Challenges Complicate Recovery
The Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) has kept a watchful eye on Boeing following a series of quality and safety challenges earlier this year, including a mid-air panel blowout on a 737 MAX aircraft. With regulatory oversight already heightened, the ongoing strike adds another layer of complexity to Boeing’s recovery efforts. Reaching pre-strike production levels could take up to a year after labor disputes are settled, particularly if the supply chain is weakened by layoffs and furloughs.
Kelly Ortberg, Boeing’s CEO, underscored the urgency of restoring production quickly but acknowledged the difficulties in reactivating a network that has been forced into hibernation.
"Once we get back, we have the task of restarting the factories and the supply chain, and it's much harder to turn this on than it is to turn it off," Ortberg said on a recent analyst call.
Financial Ripples: Stock Prices and Market Reactions
As the strike lingers, Boeing suppliers are feeling the financial pinch. Notably, Spirit AeroSystems’ shares fell by 3%, Honeywell’s by 5%, and Howmet Aerospace’s by 2% on Thursday following weak earnings reports linked to the Boeing strike. Analysts believe these numbers reflect investor concerns about a potential prolonged strike and the consequential challenges in the aerospace sector. The longer the impasse, the deeper the stock market’s apprehension, potentially leading to even further downturns in supplier performance.
Could This Strike Change Boeing’s Future Production Plans?
For Boeing, a crucial aspect of the post-strike phase will be reassembling its fractured supply chain and regaining momentum in its 737 MAX production line. Southwest Airlines Chief Operating Officer Andrew Watterson cautioned that Boeing's ability to meet demand hinges on a prompt resolution to the strike. If disruptions continue, airlines relying on Boeing aircraft may also see ripple effects in delayed aircraft deliveries and fleet updates.
Looking Forward: An Uncertain Road Ahead
The consequences of this labor strike are casting a long shadow over Boeing and its supply chain, underscoring the complexities of modern aerospace manufacturing. Small suppliers like Independent Forge are emblematic of the industry-wide challenge, facing reduced production hours and layoffs as they strive to weather the storm. Whether the strike will end soon remains uncertain, but each passing day compounds the challenges in restarting and stabilizing Boeing's production lines.
For Boeing, navigating this period of turmoil will likely involve finding new strategies to support its supplier base, minimize workforce reductions, and ensure that its commercial aircraft production can meet the growing demand for air travel in a post-pandemic world.
With Inputs from Reuters
Read next
SriLankan Adds Convenient Daytime Service Between Bangalore and Colombo – Perfect for Quick Escapes!
Abhishek Nayar
26 Oct 2024
SriLankan Airlines is set to expand its popular Bangalore-Colombo route with a new daytime flight, starting October 31, 2024. This addition brings the total number of weekly flights between these two cities to 10, giving travelers more flexible options for a quick and efficient getaway to Sri Lanka. With its strategic schedule, the new service caters to both vacationers and business travelers seeking short but enriching trips to the island nation.
New Daytime Schedule to Maximize Your Sri Lankan Experience
Beginning Thursday, October 31, SriLankan Airlines will operate Flight UL 1174 from Bangalore to Colombo every Thursday, Friday, and Saturday, departing at 9:40 AM and arriving in Colombo at 11:10 AM. This timing is ideal for Indian travelers looking to make the most of their day upon arrival in Sri Lanka, packing in sightseeing, leisure, or business meetings right from the get-go.
The return journey, Flight UL 1173, will take off from Colombo at 7:20 AM, reaching Bangalore by 8:40 AM on the same days. This timing allows passengers to return to Bangalore conveniently, ready to kick off their workweek fresh and rejuvenated after an inspiring weekend away.
Convenience and Comfort Designed for Indian Travelers
With a total of 10 weekly flights between Bangalore and Colombo, SriLankan Airlines is setting a new standard in travel flexibility. The new service not only brings in additional capacity but also aligns with peak travel times, making it the perfect weekend option for those planning a short holiday or a “workation” in Sri Lanka.
For members of the FlySmiLes frequent flyer program, the new flights also offer an opportunity to earn miles on each leg of the journey: 1,174 miles on UL 1174 and 1,173 miles on UL 1173. This added benefit allows loyal travelers to accumulate rewards while enjoying an exceptional onboard experience, complete with delicious Indian vegetarian and non-vegetarian meal options, alongside the airline's trademark hospitality.
Sri Lanka’s Rising Popularity Among Indian Travelers
Sri Lanka has become a favored destination for Indian travelers due to its close cultural and geographical proximity. From serene beach resorts to historical temples and vibrant cities, the island offers a diverse array of experiences, all within a compact area that makes short trips especially rewarding. The new SriLankan Airlines schedule aligns perfectly with the growing trend of weekend travel, giving Indians the chance to savor Sri Lanka's rich history, stunning landscapes, and bustling shopping districts in just a few days.
Beyond the allure of the island’s cultural familiarity and friendly atmosphere, Sri Lanka’s popularity as a MICE (Meetings, Incentives, Conferences, and Exhibitions) destination has been steadily growing in the Indian market. SriLankan Airlines’ enhanced connectivity and convenient flight schedules make it easier than ever for Indian business travelers to attend events, conferences, and networking sessions in Sri Lanka, opening up a wealth of opportunities.
Why Choose SriLankan Airlines?
As the only international airline offering service between nine Indian cities and Sri Lanka, SriLankan Airlines stands out as the top choice for Indian travelers. With almost 90 weekly flights operating between India and Sri Lanka, the airline connects major cities such as Delhi, Mumbai, Hyderabad, Kochi, Trivandrum, Chennai, Trichy, Madurai, and now offers enhanced access to Bangalore as well. This extensive network, combined with FlySmiLes benefits and exemplary customer service, gives travelers a seamless experience from booking to arrival.
The new flight timing between Bangalore and Colombo not only increases travel convenience but also enables more meaningful, immersive experiences in Sri Lanka. Whether it’s for a weekend adventure or a brief business trip, SriLankan Airlines’ latest addition ensures that travelers have the flexibility they need to plan the perfect itinerary, making the most out of every moment spent on the island.
Plan Your Weekend Getaway with SriLankan Airlines!
With its pristine beaches, historical landmarks, vibrant cities, and exceptional hospitality, Sri Lanka is the ultimate destination for Indian travelers seeking an exotic yet familiar getaway. Thanks to SriLankan Airlines’ new daytime flights, embarking on this adventure is now more convenient than ever. Book your tickets now to experience Sri Lanka with the ease and comfort of SriLankan Airlines, and make the most out of every trip!
Read next
Are Air Taxis the Future of India’s Urban Transportation?
Jaideep Mirchandani
26 Oct 2024
With rapid urbanization and increasing traffic congestion, the need for innovative solutions in India’s transportation system has never been more urgent. Recent developments in vertical take-off and landing (VTOL) technology, commonly known as air taxis, suggest that the future of Indian urban mobility could soon take to the skies. India’s civil aviation leaders and global tech innovators are exploring the feasibility of this aerial revolution, following a groundbreaking statement from Prime Minister Narendra Modi, who hinted at the upcoming reality of air taxis in India.
Setting the Stage: Regulatory and Technological Advancements
At the recent APAC civil aviation ministers’ conference, Modi’s announcement on air taxis highlighted the transformative potential of VTOL aircraft for urban transport. The Directorate General of Civil Aviation (DGCA) has released an advisory circular to establish safety standards and airworthiness criteria for eVTOL technology in India. This guideline outlines criteria for aircraft design, flight performance, and flight crew interfaces, all essential for the development and certification of electric air taxis.
According to Jaideep Mirchandani, Chairman of Sky One, the circular is a crucial first step toward shaping a safer, more accessible, and environmentally sustainable mode of urban air transport. “This framework provides clarity on infrastructure and safety protocols, which will reduce uncertainty for manufacturers and help pave the way for air taxis in India,” Mirchandani remarked.
Global Inspiration and Local Adaptation: The Case of Air Taxis in Developed Markets
India is not alone in exploring air taxi services; developed markets like the United States and the UAE are already pioneering similar projects. California-based Joby Aviation, for instance, has entered into a partnership with the UAE government to introduce air taxis by 2025, potentially making the UAE the first country with a fully regulated, operational air taxi system.
Global players, including Archer Aviation, backed by industry giants like Stellantis and Boeing, are also setting their sights on India as a testing ground for their advanced eVTOL technology. With air taxi trials expected to begin in 2025, India could quickly become a leader in this emerging sector, setting the stage for widespread adoption across Asia.
The Environmental Advantage: Sustainable Urban Mobility
India’s push towards greener transportation solutions aligns seamlessly with the zero-emission capabilities of eVTOL technology. Air taxis offer a unique solution to reduce carbon footprints while providing high-speed connectivity between densely populated areas. By alleviating traffic congestion and reducing ground-level pollution, air taxis hold the promise of a cleaner and more efficient future for India’s urban areas.
Mr. Mirchandani notes that zero-emission air taxis will initially connect city centers to airports, providing a fast and eco-friendly transit option. "The reduction in emissions is one of the most significant benefits of air taxis," he says. "If scaled correctly, they can revolutionize urban transport economics while providing an environmentally sustainable solution."
Challenges and Hurdles: Integrating Air Taxis into India’s Airspace
While the benefits are clear, challenges remain. Integrating air taxis into Indian airspace without disrupting current commercial aviation schedules poses a significant hurdle. Additionally, finding space for vertiports — the designated take-off and landing sites for air taxis — in India’s highly congested cities will require careful planning. Safety, reliability, and public acceptance are all key issues that regulators and industry stakeholders must address to ensure a smooth transition from concept to reality.
Regulatory frameworks are expected to expand, covering more comprehensive standards for vertiport infrastructure, battery charging, site clearance, and airspace usage. This structured approach could provide a balanced solution to ensure safety without stifling innovation.
Future Prospects: Redefining Urban Mobility Across India
The introduction of air taxis in India has the potential to transform urban transportation, creating new business opportunities while catering to the needs of diverse city populations. For now, air taxis might initially serve high-demand routes within major cities. However, as regulatory frameworks develop and operational models prove successful, the service could expand to include Tier II and Tier III cities, offering a broader demographic access to this fast, convenient, and eco-friendly mode of travel.
"Transitioning from chartered flights for the elite to a feasible option for city-to-city travel will be a gradual process,” Mirchandani explains. While the initial target market may include corporate and business commuters, the goal is to eventually offer an affordable option for the general public, providing a new dimension of connectivity within India.
Conclusion: A Vision of India’s Airborne Future
India’s journey toward adopting air taxis reflects a forward-thinking approach to solving urban transportation challenges. By embracing this aerial mobility innovation, India stands poised to redefine how we think about urban commuting. With regulatory support, private sector innovation, and public acceptance, air taxis could soon become an integral part of India’s cityscapes, offering fast, sustainable, and efficient travel solutions for millions.
As the DGCA and industry experts work toward the safe deployment of air taxis, India’s airborne future may soon become a thrilling reality — one that could elevate not only the urban landscape but the entire nation’s approach to transport and sustainability.
Read next
LATAM Soars Back with Upgraded 2024 Earnings Outlook
Abhishek Nayar
25 Oct 2024
LATAM Airlines, South America’s largest airline group, has taken a monumental step forward in its recovery journey. In a landmark move, the Santiago-based carrier returned to the New York Stock Exchange (NYSE) this July after a three-year hiatus, a period marked by financial turmoil during the pandemic. The airline's relisting signals a new chapter, marked by optimism and robust performance, as highlighted by the company during its recent investor event in New York.
Roberto Alvo, CEO of LATAM Airlines, voiced the company's pride in this achievement, stating, "We are very proud because we are returning to the main stock market in the world at a great time."
Strong Financial Projections for 2024: A Leap in EBITDAR
During its investor day, LATAM Airlines made waves with an upgrade to its earnings outlook for 2024. The company now projects EBITDAR (Earnings Before Interest, Taxes, Depreciation, Amortization, and Rent costs) to land between $3 billion and $3.15 billion, an improvement from the previously forecasted $2.75 billion to $3.05 billion. This upward revision is a testament to LATAM’s robust financial recovery post-pandemic, positioning it as a strong player in the global aviation market.
"This has been a year marked by solid results in different areas, which has allowed us to update the financial projections very positively for 2024," Alvo shared, underscoring the company’s strategic wins across multiple business segments.
Passenger Growth on the Rise: A Positive Forecast for 2024
In addition to upgraded earnings, LATAM Airlines is forecasting notable passenger growth in 2024, estimating a 15% to 16% increase compared to last year. This surge reflects a resurgence in travel demand across South America and beyond, as LATAM expands its reach and enhances its services.
With this growth trajectory, the airline is positioning itself to capture more market share, particularly in key markets across Latin America, North America, and Europe, where it continues to bolster its flight network.
A Rebuilding Process Rooted in Resilience
LATAM’s journey back to the NYSE has been anything but easy. The airline was forced to delist in 2020 as the COVID-19 pandemic wreaked havoc across the aviation industry, pushing LATAM into bankruptcy. However, through a meticulously executed restructuring plan, LATAM emerged stronger, completing its financial reorganization in November 2022. Since then, it has focused on stabilizing operations, cutting costs, and leveraging new growth opportunities.
The relisting not only marks LATAM’s return to the world’s premier stock market but also reflects the airline's solid financial foundation and renewed investor confidence.
Looking Ahead: What Does 2024 Hold for LATAM Airlines?
As LATAM looks to the future, its strengthened financials, growing passenger base, and renewed presence on the NYSE are all signals of a company poised for sustained success. Investors and industry watchers alike are eagerly awaiting what the airline has in store as it navigates the skies of recovery and growth.
With updated earnings guidance and a forward-looking strategy, LATAM Airlines is ready to take off—this time, with momentum and confidence on its side.
Final Thoughts: The New Era for LATAM
The airline’s remarkable turnaround story, from bankruptcy to relisting on the NYSE, offers a glimpse of resilience in the face of adversity. As LATAM Airlines continues to elevate its financial performance and expand its operations, 2024 could very well be a breakout year for the company.
Investors are watching closely, as LATAM's upgraded projections and solid growth outlook suggest the airline is soaring towards new heights.
With Inputs from Reuters
Comment