The saga surrounding the bankruptcy of Go First, formerly known as GoAir, continues to unfold with dramatic twists and turns. In a significant development, the Directorate General of Civil Aviation (DGCA) has deregistered all 54 aircraft leased to the defunct airline, following a directive from the Delhi High Court. This move marks a pivotal moment in the ongoing battle between lessors, creditors, and potential bidders for control of the airline.
The Court's Directive and DGCA's Response
On April 26, the Delhi High Court issued an order instructing the DGCA to deregister planes leased to Go First within a tight timeframe of five working days. This decision provided a ray of hope for lessors who have been entangled in a protracted legal battle to reclaim their aircraft since Go First filed for bankruptcy in May 2023. The DGCA swiftly complied with the court order, paving the way for lessors to take back possession of their planes.
Lessors' Relief and Ongoing Challenges
Ajay Kumar of KLA Legal, representing various lessors, hailed the DGCA's action as a "major victory" but cautioned that the battle is far from over. While deregistration allows lessors to reclaim their aircraft, the process of exporting them out of the country presents its own set of challenges. Nevertheless, the court's intervention has provided much-needed relief to lessors who have been embroiled in a complex legal quagmire.
Reputation Redemption and Global Impact
Nitin Sarin of Sarin & Co echoed sentiments of relief, emphasizing that the DGCA's move, coupled with the High Court judgment, will help restore India's reputation tarnished by the Go First debacle. The plight of lessors, as expressed by global aircraft and engine lessors at an aviation event earlier this year, underscores the far-reaching impact of Go First's bankruptcy on the aviation industry.
The Resolution Process and Prospective Bidders
The deregistration of Go First planes raises questions about the ongoing resolution process of the airline. Sharjah-based aviation company Sky One has submitted a bid, indicating continued interest in salvaging the carrier. Additionally, a joint bid led by SpiceJet promoter Ajay Singh and EaseMyTrip founder & CEO Nishant Pitti-backed Busy Bee underscores the competitive landscape of potential bidders vying for control of Go First.
Conclusion
As the dust settles on the deregistration saga, the bankruptcy battle of Go First enters a new phase. While the DGCA's action provides a glimmer of hope for lessors, challenges persist in the journey towards resolution. The fate of Go First remains uncertain, but amidst the turbulence, potential bidders stand ready to navigate the skies of opportunity in the quest to revive the airline.
With Inputs from Business Standards
Read next
As Tata Group continues its ambitious journey in the aviation sector, recent allegations of mismanagement and inequality within its subsidiary, Air India Express, raise pertinent questions about the state of affairs in the conglomerate's airline business. The Air India Express Employees Union (AIXEU) has voiced concerns over various issues, ranging from disparities in treatment to significant salary cuts, prompting a closer examination of the situation.
Allegations of Mismanagement
The registered union representing a segment of Air India Express's cabin crew has penned a letter addressed to top executives, including Tata Group and Air India Chairman N Chandrasekaran. Among the grievances highlighted are claims of mismanagement affecting employee morale. The union alleges that despite the airline's consistent profitability, various allowances, including House Rent Allowance (HRA), have been removed, resulting in substantial salary reductions.
Unequal Treatment and Lack of Transparency
One of the core issues raised by the union is the perceived lack of equality in the treatment of employees. Allegations suggest that internal job postings for higher ranks have favored external candidates over qualified internal applicants. Furthermore, concerns have been raised about the suppression of dissenting voices within the company, with management allegedly silencing grievances on company platforms.
Impact on Employee Morale and Operations
With Air India Express employing around 2,000 cabin crew members, the alleged disparities and management practices have undoubtedly had repercussions on employee morale. Such discontentment among the workforce can potentially impact operational efficiency and customer service standards, crucial elements in the highly competitive aviation industry.
Tata Group's Airline Consolidation Strategy
Tata Group's acquisition of Air India and Air India Express in 2022 signaled its intent to consolidate its presence in the aviation sector. However, recent developments cast a shadow on this strategy, raising concerns about the effective integration of the acquired entities and the management of human resources within the conglomerate's airline business.
Broader Challenges in Tata Group's Aviation Portfolio
The turbulence faced by Air India Express is not an isolated incident within Tata Group's aviation portfolio. Vistara, another subsidiary of the conglomerate, recently grappled with flight disruptions due to pilot woes and protests against new contract terms. These challenges highlight broader issues within the conglomerate's airline business, necessitating a closer scrutiny of management practices and employee relations.
Conclusion
As allegations of mismanagement and inequality swirl within Air India Express, Tata Group finds itself at a crossroads in its aviation journey. Addressing these concerns promptly and transparently is imperative to safeguarding the conglomerate's reputation and ensuring the smooth functioning of its airline business. With the aviation industry poised for recovery post-pandemic, Tata Group must prioritize fostering a positive work environment and nurturing a culture of transparency and fairness within its subsidiaries. Only then can it navigate the skies with confidence and emerge as a formidable player in the competitive aviation landscape.
Read next
The Delhi High Court, on Wednesday, granted SpiceJet a final chance to settle a payment of Rs 50 crore to its engine lessors, Team France and Sunbird France. If the airline fails to meet this obligation, it risks having two of its engines grounded, according to a report in The Economic Times (ET).
Justice Pratibha Singh instructed the counsel representing SpiceJet to obtain guidance by May 3 regarding the feasible time period for the low-cost carrier to pay Rs 50 crore to its lessors. Additionally, the airline was asked to determine if the engine that was already out of operation could be returned to the lessors.
Currently, the total outstanding amount stands at $10.84 million. Since the filing of the lawsuit in December last year, SpiceJet has already paid more than $5 million, the report said.
Issuing a firm warning to SpiceJet regarding its overdue payments, the judge stated that if the outstanding amount remains unpaid, the airline will be compelled to have two of its engines grounded.
The High Court observed that, based on its previous actions, the airline defaulted on paying the user charges. It noted the assertions made by SpiceJet's counsel that the airline is fully committed to settling the dues. The counsel argued that any adverse rulings, including grounding the engines, would not be beneficial and would instead increase the airline's financial troubles by reducing its revenue streams, the ET reported.
In December last year, Team France 01 SAS and Sunbird France 02 SAS moved the High Court, claiming that SpiceJet had failed to fulfil its past financial obligations to them for over two years. They sought an injunction to prevent SpiceJet from using their three engines following the termination of the lease agreement, as well as compensation for the outstanding dues, the ET report stated.
The lessors of the engines requested the High Court to instruct SpiceJet to surrender the engines to them
Read next
The global air passenger demand in March rose to 13.8% in comparison to the year-ago period, as per the data provided by the International Air Transport Association (IATA). The total demand is measured in revenue passenger kilometres (RPKs).
Total capacity, which is measured in available seat kilometres (ASK), was also up 12.3% YoY. The March load factor for the global airline industry was up just 1% YoY at 82.0%.
Willie Walsh, IATA’s Director General, said, “Demand for travel is strong and there is every indication that this should continue into the peak Northern Summer travel season. It is critical that we have the capacity to meet this demand. There is a need to make urgent progress to resolve supply chain issues. The airports and air traffic management should ensure that be fully staffed and operating at maximum efficiency."
As per the IATA data, domestic demand was up 6.6% YoY and capacity increased to 3.4% YoY. The load factor improved by 2.5% to 82.6% YoY. Domestic demand increased at a slower pace in March, moderating pre-pandemic growth rates.
China continued to lead the global markets with an increase of 17.6%. Other markets showed stable growth, apart from Australia. The report said, "Australia's drop in growth may reflect the wider economic slowdown in Q1 in the country.”
The domestic demand in India was up 3.8% YoY and the capacity in terms of available seat kilometres (ASK) also hiked 3.5% YoY, as per the data. However, the passenger load factor was merely 0.2%, with India's share in the global markets standing at just 1.8%.
All regions showed strong growth in international passenger markets in March 2024. The Asia-Pacific airlines continue to lead all regions, with a 38.5% year-on-year increase in demand. Their capacity increased to 37.4% YoY. The load factor, which was the highest among all regions, rose to 85.6%.
While the number of scheduled services from China to North America is only at 16.5% of pre-pandemic levels, the major routes from Asia-Pacific displayed outstanding growth.
The demand for European carriers increased by 11.6% YoY. Capacity was up 11.4% YoY, and the load factor stood at 79.9% YoY. The Middle Eastern airlines recorded a 10.8% YoY increase in demand. While the capacity increased to 13.9% YoY, the load factor dropped by 2.1% to 77.5% YoY.
The North American carriers saw an increase in demand by 14.5% YoY. The capacity increased 14.8% YoY, and the load factor dropped by 0.2% to 84.7% YoY. The Latin American airlines recorded a 19.7% increase in YoY demand. The capacity climbed 18.3% YoY and the load factor rose to 84.3%.
The African airlines saw a single-digit growth in demand of 8.1% YoY. While the capacity was up 11.0% YoY, the load factor fell by almost 2% to 70.3%.
Read next
In a bid to uphold consumer trust and combat deceptive environmental marketing, the European Commission, in collaboration with national consumer protection authorities, has initiated legal action against 20 airlines for engaging in misleading greenwashing practices. This significant move underscores the EU's commitment to ensuring that environmental claims made by businesses are substantiated by robust scientific evidence.
The Allegations Unveiled
The EU's action follows concerns raised over airlines' assertions regarding the extent to which carbon dioxide (CO2) emissions from flights can be offset through climate projects or the utilization of sustainable aviation fuels. Despite mounting pressure for transparency, several airlines have been accused of disseminating vague or false claims, thereby misleading consumers about the true environmental impact of air travel.
While the statement released by the EU refrained from disclosing the names of the implicated airlines, citing the preliminary stage of the investigation, it affirmed collaboration with Belgian, Dutch, Norwegian, and Spanish watchdogs in this endeavor. This concerted effort reflects a united front in addressing the issue of greenwashing within the aviation industry.
Demand for Accountability
EU Commissioner for Values and Transparency, Vera Jourova, emphasized the importance of providing consumers with accurate and scientifically grounded information. She asserted that responsible consumers deserve nothing less than truthful disclosures regarding the environmental footprint of their choices. The call for accountability echoes across borders, transcending national jurisdictions to uphold integrity in environmental marketing practices.
Legal Precedent: The KLM Case
The crackdown on greenwashing comes in the wake of a landmark ruling by a Dutch court against KLM, a prominent airline, for deceptive advertising practices aimed at burnishing its environmental image. The court found KLM guilty of misleading customers, signaling a pivotal moment in the fight against corporate greenwashing. This legal precedent serves as a stark warning to airlines and underscores the repercussions of deceptive marketing tactics.
Toward a Sustainable Future
As the aviation industry grapples with the imperative to reduce its carbon footprint, transparency and accountability emerge as cornerstones of progress. The EU's decisive action sends a clear message: unsubstantiated environmental claims will not be tolerated. Moving forward, stakeholders must prioritize authenticity and integrity in their sustainability efforts, fostering a culture of trust and responsibility in consumer communication.
Conclusion
The EU's crackdown on airlines for greenwashing practices marks a pivotal step in safeguarding consumer interests and promoting environmental stewardship. By holding businesses accountable for the accuracy of their environmental claims, authorities are paving the way for a more transparent and sustainable future. As the investigation unfolds, the spotlight remains on the aviation industry, urging stakeholders to embrace transparency and uphold the highest standards of integrity in environmental marketing.
With Inputs from Reuters
Read next
The first quarter of 2024 brought unexpected challenges for European airline giants Lufthansa and Air France-KLM. Labor disputes, capacity limitations, and flight disruptions deepened their losses, prompting both companies to announce cost-cutting measures. Despite a backdrop of increasing travel demand post-pandemic, these airlines find themselves grappling with higher costs and uncertain market conditions.
Labor Disputes and Flight Disruptions
The first quarter, traditionally challenging for airlines, proved exceptionally difficult for Lufthansa and Air France-KLM. Expensive strike actions and disruptions due to capacity limits and cancellations exacerbated their financial woes. Lufthansa reported heavy losses from strikes, while Air France-KLM faced significant compensation payouts, primarily to customers affected by cancellations.
Cost-Cutting Measures
In response to the financial strain, both airlines unveiled strategies to tighten spending and mitigate losses. Air France-KLM announced a freeze on hiring support staff, while Lufthansa outlined plans to cut operating costs, pause new projects, and scrutinize administrative staffing. These measures reflect a concerted effort to address the root causes of financial distress and streamline operations.
Financial Outlook and Market Response
The market response to the first-quarter results varied. While Lufthansa revised its full-year outlook downwards, Air France-KLM maintained its 2024 outlook but warned of continued cost increases in the second quarter. Despite the challenges, hopes for a summer demand surge buoyed optimism among investors, with both airlines anticipating a strong summer season.
Navigating Uncertain Terrain
Despite the optimism surrounding summer travel, uncertainties persist. Both airlines emphasized the completion of collective bargaining agreements and expressed confidence in avoiding further disruptions. Additionally, geopolitical tensions, such as the fallout from conflicts in the Middle East, continue to impact route performance and passenger confidence.
Challenges Ahead and Conclusion
Looking ahead, challenges remain on the horizon. Slow demand recovery, particularly from key markets like China, poses a significant hurdle. Moreover, rising repair and maintenance costs, coupled with ongoing capacity constraints, raise questions about the sustainability of recovery efforts. Analysts have voiced concerns about whether robust demand will be sufficient to lift airlines out of their financial difficulties.
As Lufthansa and Air France-KLM navigate the complexities of a post-pandemic travel landscape, they face a delicate balancing act between cost containment and meeting growing passenger expectations. While summer demand offers a glimmer of hope, the path to financial stability remains fraught with challenges. Effective cost-cutting measures and strategic planning will be crucial as these airlines chart a course towards recovery in the months ahead.
With Inputs from Reuters
Comment