Are Surprise Fees on the Way Out? US Budget Airlines Embrace Transparency

Abhishek Nayar

23 May 2024

In a significant shift for the budget airline industry, Frontier Airlines and Spirit Airlines have introduced measures to reduce or eliminate surprise fees for consumers. This move, potentially influenced by new US legislation, aims to enhance transparency and improve customer satisfaction.

Frontier Airlines: The New Frontier in Transparency

On May 17th, Frontier Airlines announced a comprehensive overhaul of its fee structure, marking a pivotal step in rebranding itself as "The New Frontier." This initiative includes introducing four new airfare bundles that incorporate various amenities, echoing the model of 'hybrid' carriers like Breeze Airways.

Four New Airfare Bundles

  • Basic: Minimal amenities, change fees still applicable.
  • Standard, Premium, and Business: Increased benefits, including the elimination of change fees.

Barry Biffle, Frontier's CEO, emphasized that these changes are part of the airline’s commitment to making travel with Frontier as flexible and worry-free as possible. The headline feature of eliminating change fees, however, applies only to the top three tiers, leaving Basic package customers still liable for last-minute changes.

Additionally, Frontier is reinstating live phone support for customers within 24 hours of their flight or those with Elite status, extending flight credit validity from three to twelve months, and offering a "For Less" guarantee. This guarantee awards members 2,500 FRONTIER Miles if they find a comparable flight on the same route and date for a lower price elsewhere.

Spirit Airlines: A Broad Sweep of Changes

Following Frontier’s announcement, Spirit Airlines unveiled its own set of changes, notably eliminating change and cancellation fees for all ticket fares, including the basic economy package. This move is a significant departure from the previous tiered fee structure based on the proximity to the departure date:

  • $119 for changes made 0 to 6 days before departure.
  • $99 for changes made 7 to 30 days prior.
  • $69 for changes made between 31 and 59 days before departure.

Spirit had previously offered a 24-hour grace period for accidental bookings, allowing changes or cancellations without penalties. The elimination of these fees marks a significant improvement in customer experience and aligns with the broader industry trend towards greater fee transparency.

Industry Trends and Governmental Influence

Ancillary fees, often seen as a critical revenue stream for airlines, have come under increasing scrutiny. According to the US Bureau of Transportation Statistics, airline revenue from baggage fees grew by over 30% between 2018 and 2022, outpacing overall operating revenue growth.

The Biden administration has prioritized addressing these fees, culminating in new rules from the Department of Transportation (DOT) to protect passengers from "surprise junk fees." These rules mandate that airlines and ticket agents disclose upfront fees for checked and carry-on bags and for changing or canceling reservations.

US Transportation Secretary Pete Buttigieg highlighted the anticipated consumer savings of up to $500 million per year, stating, “Airlines should compete with one another to secure passengers’ business—not to see who can charge the most in surprise fees.”

The Road Ahead: Implications for Low-Cost Carriers

The recent changes by Frontier and Spirit raise questions about the future of low-cost carriers (LCCs) in the United States. While governmental pressure has led to the collapse of some LCCs worldwide, others have adapted and thrived. The impact of these changes on ticket prices and overall customer savings remains to be seen.

The DOT’s ongoing efforts, including a proposed rule to ban fees for family seating assignments, indicate a continued focus on consumer protection. As the industry adjusts, it will be crucial to monitor how other carriers respond and whether these measures genuinely result in the predicted savings for consumers.

Conclusion

The recent fee structure changes by Frontier and Spirit Airlines mark a significant shift towards greater transparency and customer-friendly practices in the US budget airline industry. While the full impact of these changes remains uncertain, the move represents a positive step towards reducing the financial burden on travelers and fostering a more competitive market.

Read next

Domestic Air Passenger Traffic Sees a 3.88% Increase in April

Abhishek Nayar

23 May 2024

The skies over India are bustling with more activity as domestic air passenger traffic experienced a notable rise of 3.88% in April 2024 compared to the same month last year. According to the latest data released by the Directorate General of Civil Aviation (DGCA), the number of passengers surged to 1.32 crore from 1.28 crore in April 2023. This trend highlights the continued recovery and growth in the aviation sector.

Rising Numbers and Unforeseen Hiccups

The DGCA data revealed that the domestic airlines carried 523.46 lakh passengers between January and April 2024, marking an annual growth of 3.88%. This growth underscores a steady rebound in air travel demand post-pandemic, with a 2.42% monthly increase observed in April alone.

Despite the positive growth in passenger traffic, not all news was smooth sailing. A total of 1,370 passengers faced denied boarding in April. Airlines spent a considerable Rs 136.23 lakh to compensate and provide facilities to these affected passengers. Flight cancellations were also significant, with 32,314 flights not taking off as planned. Compensation and facilities for these cancellations amounted to Rs 89.26 lakh.

Delays and On-Time Performance

Flight delays were another challenge, with 1,09,910 flights experiencing delays in April. Airlines had to shell out Rs 135.42 lakh to manage these delays and provide facilitation to passengers. On-Time Performance (OTP) varied among airlines, with Akasa Air leading the pack at 89.2%. The performance of other airlines is as follows:

Market Dynamics and The Road Ahead

The competitive landscape of domestic airlines saw some shifts in market shares. IndiGo continued to dominate with a slight increase to 60.6%, maintaining its stronghold as the market leader. Air India also saw a rise in its market share to 14.2%. However, Vistara and AIX Connect experienced declines, dropping to 9.2% and 5.4% respectively. Akasa Air's market share remained steady at 4.4%, while SpiceJet saw a decrease to 4.7%.

The growth in domestic air passenger traffic is a promising sign for the aviation industry, indicating a recovery trend. However, the challenges of denied boardings, flight cancellations, and delays highlight the need for airlines to enhance operational efficiency and passenger services. The industry must focus on improving OTP and minimizing disruptions to sustain this growth trajectory.

Conclusion

As the Indian skies become busier, the rise in domestic air passenger traffic is a positive development for the aviation sector. The DGCA's latest data paints a picture of growth interspersed with operational challenges that need to be addressed. Airlines will have to balance this growth with improved service quality to ensure a seamless travel experience for passengers.

Read next

Go First' Creditor Auction: Prime Thane Land to Fetch Crores Amid Bleak Revival Hopes

Abhishek Nayar

22 May 2024

Creditors of the defunct Go First are gearing up for a significant auction, targeting a prime 94-acre land parcel in Thane near Mumbai. The reserve price for this coveted property has been set at approximately Rs.1,960 crore. The formal auction process is expected to commence soon, with advertisements slated to appear in newspapers this week, according to sources close to the matter.

A Glimmer of Hope in a Bleak Scenario

This auction comes at a critical juncture as the prospects of reviving Go First grow increasingly dim. The Delhi High Court's recent decision to allow lessors to deregister and reclaim 54 Go First aircraft has severely impacted the airline's valuation. With little left to salvage, creditors are turning to the land asset to recoup some of their losses.

Auction Details and Timeline

"The formal auction process will start after the ads are released in a few newspapers later this week. All lenders have given their go-ahead for the publishing of the ads. Potential bidders will be given about 60 days to make an offer for the land," stated an informed source. This timeline aims to attract serious bids, giving potential buyers ample time to evaluate the opportunity.

Valuation and Development Potential

The land parcel, situated in a prime location in Thane, has been valued at around ?1,200 crore based on current market conditions. However, considering its development potential and future cash flows, its value could soar to at least Rs.2,500 crore. This property was pledged as collateral by the Wadia group for loans taken by Go First and is owned by the group's realty arm.

Sale Conditions and Liabilities

Lenders plan to offer the land on an "as-is, where-is" basis, which means that bidders will inherit any future tax, government, or other liabilities associated with the property. Notably, about four acres of the land have already been taken over by the Thane Municipal Corporation for road widening and beautification, which will need to be factored into the bids.

Dwindling Airline Assets and Creditor Deliberations

The court's decision to allow the deregistration of planes significantly diminishes what remains of Go First as a viable business. Creditors are still in discussions about the next steps, with the current deadline for these deliberations set for June 4. An extension is likely, as the two bidders in contention— a consortium of Nishant Piti, CEO of EaseMyTrip, and Ajay Singh, chairman of SpiceJet, alongside Sharjah-based Sky One Aviation—reassess their strategies in light of recent developments.

Bidders' Offers and Future Arbitration Claims

Both bidders have factored future arbitration claims from Go First's legal proceedings against engine manufacturer Pratt & Whitney into their proposals. Sky One Aviation has put forth a bid offering Rs.735 crore upfront in cash and a share of up to 20% of future arbitration claims. Conversely, Ajay Singh's consortium has proposed a payment of Rs.650 crore over 12 months plus 10% of arbitration claims.

Creditor Landscape and Stakes

Go First owes over Rs.6,200 crore to its creditors. Among the secured creditors, Central Bank of India, Bank of Baroda, and IDBI Bank hold the highest stakes, with admitted claims amounting to Rs.1,934 crore, Rs.1,744 crore, and Rs.75 crore, respectively.

Conclusion

The upcoming auction of the Thane land parcel represents a critical move by creditors to recover their dues amidst the unraveling of Go First. While the land's prime location and development potential are significant draws, the complex liabilities and uncertain future value add layers of risk for potential bidders. As the auction unfolds, it will be a closely watched event, with implications not just for the creditors and bidders, but for the broader market as well.

With Inputs from Economic Times

Read next

Iberia to Lead the Way with Airbus A321neo (XLR)

Abhishek Nayar

22 May 2024

In a significant reshuffle within the International Airlines Group (IAG), Iberia has been confirmed as the global launch operator of the much-anticipated Airbus A321neo (XLR). This decision follows IAG’s strategic move to reallocate the opportunity from Aer Lingus, which faced operational setbacks due to a pay dispute with the Irish Airline Pilots’ Association (IALPA).

Long-Haul Potential for a Narrowbody Aircraft

The A321neo (XLR), with its extended range capabilities, represents a new frontier for narrowbody aircraft in long-haul travel. Iberia plans to deploy this aircraft on transatlantic routes from its hub at Madrid Barajas Airport to major US destinations, including Boston and Washington Dulles. The aircraft's configuration will feature 14 business class seats and 168 economy class seats, promising comfort and efficiency on these longer routes.

Order History and Redistribution within IAG

IAG placed an order for fourteen A321neo (XLR) aircraft in 2019, originally dividing them between Aer Lingus and Iberia. Aer Lingus was slated to receive the first of these aircraft, msn 11348, designated to be registered as EI-XLR. However, labor disputes necessitated a reevaluation of fleet deployment, resulting in Iberia stepping in as the launch operator. The first A321neo (XLR) for Iberia, msn 11504, is already adorned with the airline's distinctive decals.

Regulatory Hurdles and Safety Measures

Despite the excitement, the A321neo (XLR) is still awaiting its type certificate from aviation authorities, with Airbus projecting entry into service in 2024. The US Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) has proposed special conditions focusing on the aircraft's integral rear centre tank (RCT). Given its unusual configuration, the FAA emphasized the need for enhanced safety standards, particularly the fuel-tank skin’s resilience in post-crash fire scenarios.

The FAA's notice highlights the necessity for the lower half of the fuselage to resist penetration by external fuel-fed fires, ensuring passenger safety is uncompromised despite the innovative design changes.

Global Orders and Industry Impact

Globally, the A321neo (XLR) has garnered 496 firm orders, signaling strong market confidence in its potential. Airlines are eagerly anticipating its ability to open up new routes that were previously not feasible with traditional narrowbody aircraft, promising a mix of operational efficiency and expanded service options.

Conclusion

Iberia’s role as the launch operator of the A321neo (XLR) marks a pivotal moment in aviation, blending technological advancement with strategic fleet management. As the airline prepares to introduce this cutting-edge aircraft into its operations, passengers can look forward to enhanced travel experiences on routes that bridge continents with unprecedented efficiency.

With Inputs from ch-aviation

Read next

Saudia Group's Strategic Expansion with Airbus A320neo Family

Abhishek Nayar

22 May 2024

In a landmark move set to significantly bolster Saudi Arabia's aviation sector, Saudia Group, represented by Saudia, the national flag carrier, and flyadeal, the group’s low-cost carrier, has signed a firm order for 105 Airbus A320neo Family aircraft.

The deal, comprising 12 A320neo and 93 A321neo aircraft, was unveiled at the Future Aviation Forum in Riyadh. The announcement was graced by H.E. Saleh bin Nasser Al-Jasser, Minister of Transport and Logistic Services, H.E. Engr. Ibrahim Al-Omar, Director General of Saudia Group, and Benoît de Saint-Exupéry, Executive Vice President Sales of the Commercial Aircraft business.

Strategic Expansion to Meet Growing Demand

Highlighting the airline's ambitious operational objectives, H.E. Engr. Ibrahim Al-Omar stated, "Saudia is increasing flights and seat capacity across our existing 100+ destinations on four continents, with plans for further expansion. The progress of Saudi Vision 2030 is attracting more visitors, tourists, entrepreneurs, and pilgrims each year. This motivated our decision to secure this significant deal, which will create jobs, increase local content, and contribute to the national economy."

Boosting Saudi Vision 2030

The new aircraft additions are poised to play a crucial role in the Kingdom’s Vision 2030, which aims to diversify the economy and reduce its dependency on oil. Benoît de Saint-Exupéry emphasized the alignment of this deal with the national vision, stating,

"The new additions of the A320neo family aircraft will play a vital role in contributing to Saudi Arabia's ambitious Vision 2030 plan. It will enable Saudia Group’s strategy to advance the Kingdom’s aviation capabilities while enabling both airlines to benefit from the A320neo Family’s exceptional efficiency, superior economics, highest level of passenger comfort as well as lower fuel-burn and emissions."

Enhancing Saudi Arabia's Global Tourism Strategy

Saudi Arabia is rapidly transforming into a global tourism hub, with the Saudi National Tourism Strategy targeting over 150 million tourists by 2030. The significant order of Airbus aircraft will be instrumental in realizing this goal, strengthening the Kingdom’s position as a premier global tourism destination.

Economic and Employment Benefits

The agreement with Airbus is not just a milestone for Saudia Group but also a substantial economic catalyst. The influx of new aircraft is expected to generate numerous job opportunities, enhance local industry content, and significantly contribute to the national economy. As Saudia Group expands its fleet, the ripple effects are likely to be felt across various sectors, from hospitality to retail, thereby supporting the broader objectives of Vision 2030.

A Leap Towards Sustainable Aviation

The Airbus A320neo Family aircraft are renowned for their fuel efficiency and reduced emissions, aligning with global sustainability goals. By incorporating these advanced aircraft into their fleet, Saudia and flyadeal are making a substantial commitment to environmental stewardship while enhancing their operational efficiency.

Conclusion

Saudia Group’s strategic order of 105 A320neo Family aircraft from Airbus marks a significant milestone in the Kingdom's aviation and economic landscape. This bold move is set to propel Saudi Arabia closer to its Vision 2030 objectives, fostering economic growth, creating jobs, and enhancing the country's global tourism appeal. As the Kingdom continues to attract more visitors and investors, the skies over Saudi Arabia are set to become busier and more vibrant, reflecting the nation's dynamic progress and ambitious future.

With Inputs from Airbus

Read next

Ryanair Soars to Record Profits

Abhishek Nayar

22 May 2024

Ryanair, Europe's largest low-cost airline, has soared to unprecedented financial heights, reporting its highest annual profits in history for the fiscal year ending March 31, 2024. The Ryanair Group, encompassing brands like Malta Air, Buzz, Lauda Europe, and Ryanair UK, posted a staggering profit of €1.92 billion ($2.09 billion), marking a 34% year-on-year increase.

Boosted by Passenger Traffic and Fare Hikes

Central to this financial triumph was a notable rise in passenger traffic and average fares. Ryanair's passenger numbers surged by 9%, reaching 183.7 million. This robust traffic growth, coupled with a 21% increase in yield per passenger, pushed the average yield to nearly €5 ($4.58). Ancillary revenue also saw a significant uptick, climbing 12% to an average of €23.40 ($25.50) per passenger.

Impressive Load Factors, Revenue Growth and Preparing for a Record-Breaking Summer

Ryanair’s strategic operational enhancements were evident in its load factor, which improved by one percentage point to 94%. Overall revenues leaped to €13.44 billion ($14.64 billion), a 25% increase from the previous year’s €10.78 billion.

Anticipating its busiest summer season ever, Ryanair is gearing up with a fleet exceeding 500 aircraft, including Boeing 737-800s, 737 MAX-8200s, and 27 Airbus A320s operated by Lauda Europe. The airline is set to launch five new bases and over 200 new routes.

Smart Fuel Hedging, Fleet Financing, Strong Financial Position and Future Growth

In anticipation of potential operating cost increases, Ryanair has hedged over 70% of its fuel requirements for the current financial year at just under $80 per barrel. This move is expected to save the airline an estimated €450 million ($488 million). Additionally, Ryanair’s financial stability is bolstered by its fleet financing structure. Owning its entire Boeing fleet of 556 aircraft outright, Ryanair is insulated from volatile lease rate fluctuations, unlike many competitors.

With a healthy bank balance, Ryanair ended the year with approximately €4.12 billion ($4.42 billion) in gross cash, allowing it to repay a billion euros of debt and still remain cash-rich. This financial robustness translates to significant interest earnings, contributing approximately €0.3 ($0.32) per passenger.

Facing Delivery Challenges, Market Opportunities and European Airline Market Consolidation

While Ryanair aims to grow its traffic by 8% to nearly 200 million passengers in the current year, it faces challenges due to delays in Boeing 737 MAX-8200 deliveries. Despite these hurdles, the airline plans to operate its largest-ever summer schedule, capitalizing on competitors' disruptions due to Pratt & Whitney engine repairs.

Ryanair anticipates ongoing consolidation in the European airline market throughout 2024, with significant transactions such as the takeovers of ITA (Italy) and Air Europa (Spain) and the potential sale of TAP (Portugal). These developments, combined with Ryanair’s cost advantages, strong balance sheet, and extensive aircraft orders, position the airline for sustained profitability and growth toward a target of 300 million passengers annually by 2034.

Conclusion

With strong forward bookings, strategic operational planning, and a resilient business model, Ryanair is set to continue its upward trajectory. The airline's ability to navigate challenges and leverage opportunities highlights its industry-leading resilience and bright prospects for the future.

Comment