Safran CEO Demands Criminal Probe into London Firm's Engine Scandal

Abhishek Nayar

28 Oct 2023

French engine manufacturer Safran, in partnership with GE Aerospace, has called for a criminal investigation into allegations that a London-based firm, AOG Technics, distributed falsely documented aircraft engine parts. The allegations have sent shockwaves through the aviation industry, raising concerns about the presence of uncertified parts inside high-tech jet engines and exposing regulatory gaps in the distribution of aviation components.

The Allegations

Safran and GE Aerospace, in collaboration under the joint venture CFM International, have accused AOG Technics of selling thousands of parts for the CFM56 jet engine with falsified certification documents. These engines are widely used in aircraft produced by Boeing and Airbus.

Regulatory Concerns

The allegations have prompted investigations by aviation regulators in various regions. Britain's Civil Aviation Authority initiated an investigation into the supply of suspect, unapproved parts through AOG Technics in August. Additionally, both EU and U.S. regulators have issued warnings regarding parts supplied by the London-based firm.

AOG Technics' Response

While AOG Technics has not publicly responded to the allegations, the company informed a British court last month that it was cooperating fully with investigations conducted by aviation companies and regulators.

Safran CEO's Statement

Safran CEO Olivier Andries expressed his belief and hope for a criminal investigation into this matter, emphasizing the seriousness of the allegations. He made these comments while discussing the company's quarterly results.

CFM's Response

CFM International, responsible for designing and manufacturing the CFM56 engines, took legal action against AOG Technics in the UK in September to obtain documents related to their transactions. After analyzing the documents provided by AOG Technics, CFM identified 180 falsified documents, covering 124 part numbers. Approximately half of the 145 affected engines have been repaired, with the remaining half set for treatment in the near future.

Lessons Learned

Andries noted that CFM had already taken steps to tighten its own procedures after it was revealed in court documents that the engine company had directly or indirectly purchased some of the suspect parts. This situation has highlighted the need for enhanced diligence in sourcing and verifying aircraft components.

Impact on the Industry

The distribution of counterfeit or uncertified aircraft parts has been a persistent issue in the aviation industry. However, the presence of these parts within high-tech jet engines has raised significant concerns. It has also revealed a regulatory gap, as parts distributors are not subject to the same level of control imposed on other segments of the industry.

Conclusion

The allegations against AOG Technics and the subsequent call for a criminal investigation by Safran and GE Aerospace underscore the critical importance of maintaining the integrity and authenticity of aircraft components.

The aviation industry is facing a pivotal moment as it grapples with the challenge of preventing the distribution of falsified or uncertified parts within jet engines, all while emphasizing the need for enhanced regulatory oversight in the distribution of aviation components. As the investigation unfolds, the industry will closely watch for developments and potential reforms to address these issues, ensuring the safety and reliability of aircraft engines.

With Inputs from Reuters

Read next

Chinese Airlines Post Quarterly Profits After Long Pandemic Struggle

Abhishek Nayar

28 Oct 2023

In a promising sign for the global aviation industry, China's major airlines - China Southern Airlines, China Eastern Airlines, and Air China - have reported their first quarterly profits in over three years. This positive development is attributed to the recovery of both domestic and international markets.

China Southern Airlines: A Turnaround Story

China Southern Airlines, headquartered in Guangzhou, emerged from the pandemic's challenging times to report a third-quarter profit of 4.2 billion yuan, which is equivalent to approximately $573.89 million.

This achievement marks a significant reversal from the 1.0 billion yuan loss reported in the previous quarter and the massive 6.1 billion yuan loss in the year-earlier period. The substantial improvement in the airline's financial health highlights the resilience and adaptability of the Chinese aviation industry.

China Eastern Airlines: Soaring to Profits

Shanghai-based China Eastern Airlines also posted an impressive comeback by reporting a quarterly net profit of 3.6 billion yuan. This remarkable achievement follows a loss of 2.4 billion yuan in the previous three months and an even more substantial loss of 9.4 billion yuan in the year-earlier period. The surge in profits for China Eastern Airlines underlines the industry's ability to recover and thrive in challenging circumstances.

Air China's Milestone Recovery

Flagship carrier Air China has made a significant leap towards financial recovery, with their first quarterly profit in nearly four years. Air China's third-quarter net profit stood at 4.24 billion yuan, a stark contrast to the 600 million yuan loss reported in the previous quarter and the massive 8.67 billion yuan loss in the same period the previous year. This remarkable turnaround has rekindled hope for the revival of one of China's leading airlines.

Industry-Wide Hope for Recovery

The positive results from these three major Chinese carriers are reverberating throughout the aviation industry. The Aviation regulator in China disclosed that air passenger numbers in the third quarter reached 180 million, a 2.6% increase compared to the pre-pandemic levels of 2019. This milestone not only signifies the recovery of the domestic market but also underscores the international market's resurgence.

Conclusion

The recent financial successes of China Southern Airlines, China Eastern Airlines, and Air China serve as a beacon of hope for the entire global aviation industry. The ability of these major carriers to bounce back after a prolonged pandemic-induced slump is indicative of the industry's resilience and adaptability.

With a record-breaking performance in the third quarter of 2023, it appears that the Chinese aviation sector is well on its way to leaving the difficulties brought on by the COVID-19 pandemic behind. This is not only a positive development for the industry but also a testament to the gradual recovery of the global economy. As the world continues to grapple with the pandemic's challenges, the successes of these airlines provide inspiration for the broader aviation community to strive for a brighter future.

With Inputs from Reuters

Read next

Air France-KLM Faces Turbulence as Q3 Profits Fall Short of Expectations

Abhishek Nayar

28 Oct 2023

Air France-KLM, one of Europe's major airline conglomerates, experienced a setback as its shares plummeted by up to 8% to an all-time low on Friday, October 27, 2023. The drop came in the wake of the airline's third-quarter financial report, which showed record profits but failed to meet analysts' expectations. This decline in share value raised concerns among investors about rising fuel costs and the company's lack of profit guidance for the fourth quarter.

Third-Quarter Performance

In its quarterly report, Air France-KLM revealed an operating profit of 1.34 billion euros ($1.37 billion) for the period from July to September, representing a substantial 31% increase year-on-year. While these figures indicated a healthy performance, they fell 2% short of the consensus forecast of financial analysts.

On the same day, British Airways-owner IAG, in contrast, surpassed expectations, reporting record third-quarter profits. This discrepancy suggests that despite the ongoing challenges in the aviation industry, certain players are thriving, thanks to the resurgence of travel during the summer months.

Analyst Concerns

The market's reaction to Air France-KLM's Q3 report was largely shaped by concerns raised by financial analysts. Stifel analysts, for instance, noted that the results were mixed and failed to surpass expectations. Moreover, they pointed out the absence of commentary on the yield for the fourth quarter. Additionally, the airline's decision to increase its full-year fuel cost expectations from $7.5 billion to $7.8 billion raised further eyebrows.

Uncertainty and Market Shifts

Air France-KLM's report also highlighted a growing shift in the aviation industry, influenced by the evolving travel landscape. The airline made it clear that it did not anticipate a return to pre-pandemic capacity levels in the French market. The rise of high-speed rail services like the TGV in France has provided travelers with a viable alternative to short domestic flights. This shift has resulted in a significant drop in demand for routes such as Paris-Marseille, where the train journey takes approximately three hours.

In response to this shift, the airline announced earlier in the month its plan to discontinue most of its domestic flights from Paris-Orly airport by the summer of 2026. The decision reflects the diminishing demand for domestic business flights and the growing popularity of rail travel.

Conclusion

Air France-KLM's third-quarter financial results and the subsequent market reaction underline the challenges and uncertainties facing the aviation industry in the post-pandemic era. While the company reported record profits, these figures fell short of expectations, leading to a drop in its share value. Rising fuel costs and a lack of profit guidance for the fourth quarter further contributed to investor concerns.

Moreover, the shifting dynamics of the travel market, exemplified by the company's decision to reduce domestic flights in favor of high-speed rail alternatives, highlight the need for adaptability and resilience in the airline sector. As the industry navigates these challenges, investors and analysts will closely monitor developments to gauge the long-term stability of companies like Air France-KLM in a changing travel landscape.

With Inputs from Reuters

Read next

Air India Announces Several Senior Level Appointments; Capt Klaus Goersch is the New COO

Radhika Bansal

27 Oct 2023

Air India has announced the appointment of Captain Klaus Goersch as Executive Vice President and Chief Operations Officer. He will oversee flight operations, engineering, ground operations, integrated operations control (IOCC) and cabin crew functions, the airline stated. 

Capt Goersch is a licenced B777 & B787 pilot who has held similar positions in both British Airways and Air Canada. He will be based out of Air India’s new Gurugram headquarters. He will be replacing Capt RS Sandhu who will transition to an advisory role with a focus on the synergy between the four Tata airlines’ operating procedures. Capt Sandhu, who had already extended his service with Air India beyond the superannuation date, will also be establishing Air India’s new training academy. 

In a release, Air India said Goersch’s role includes focusing on the harmonisation of the four Tata Airlines’ operating procedures, the Airbus A350 entry-into-service programme and assisting the team in establishing the carrier’s new training academy.

Air India CEO and MD Campbell Wilson, welcoming Capt Goersch said, “Having worked at some of the best airlines in the world, he brings a wealth of knowledge and experience that is valuable to the ongoing transformation at Air India.”

The airline also announced the other senior appointments to further strengthen its management team. Capt Manish Uppal, who transitioned from AirAsia India a few months ago, has been appointed as Senior Vice President of Flight Operations, while Capt Henry Donohoe will be retitled Senior Vice President of Safety, Security and Quality after the addition of emergency response to his Corporate Safety, Security and Quality role.

Pankaj Handa will lead Ground Operations, Choorah Singh will join as Divisional Vice President of Integrated Operations Control and JuLi Ng will join as Divisional Vice President Cabin Crew. They will all report to Capt Goersch. The Inflight Product & Service Design functions headed by Sandeep Verma will now be part of Rajesh Dogra's Customer Experience portfolio. 

Capt Goersch, Dogra and Capt Donohoe will report directly to Campbel Wilson, as will existing Management Committee members Nipun Aggarwal, Dr Satya Ramaswamy, Dr Suresh Dutt Tripathi and Vinod Hejmadi, whose roles remain unchanged.

Wilson said that these changes have been made to manage succession, streamline the organisation, and optimise talent from within the Tata airline group. “At Air India, we remain committed to building top leadership as we continue to invest in all the resources that are required to take the airline to the upper echelons of global aviation,” Wilson said.

Founded by JRD Tata, Air India was welcomed back into the Tata group in January 2022, after spending 69 years as a government-owned enterprise. It is currently in a five-year transformation process, under the aegis of Vihaan.AI. 

Tata Group, which took control of loss-making Air India in January last year, is in the process of consolidating its airline business. As part of the consolidation, AirAsia India (now AIX Connect) is in the process of getting merged with Air India Express, while Vistara will be merged with Air India. Vistara is a joint venture between Tatas and Singapore Airlines.

Read next

Air India & SpiceJet Complete IATA's Risk-Based Audit

Radhika Bansal

27 Oct 2023

Indian carriers SpiceJet and Air India are among the six airlines which have successfully completed the risk-based approach audit of the International Air Transport Association (IATA) - the largest trade group of global airlines, according to a report by The Economic Times. The other airlines are American Airlines. British Airways, LATAM, Luxair and Qatar Airways.

The risk-based approach audit is a new form of IATA’s operational and safety audit which is fine tuned to the particular airline’s operational requirement. This is different from the compliance-based approach.

The risk-based approach audit recognizes that aviation safety is not static but a dynamic and evolving process. With the continuous development of aircraft technologies, changes in operational environments, and a multitude of factors that contribute to flight safety, audit programs must keep pace. By embracing a risk-based approach, airlines can better tailor their safety measures to their specific operations, thereby increasing the effectiveness of their safety protocols.

This approach acknowledges that safety is not solely about meeting minimum compliance requirements. It places a greater emphasis on understanding an airline’s operations, its unique challenges, and its proactive commitment to safety. By doing so, airlines can take a more comprehensive approach to risk management, allowing them to identify potential hazards and address them before they become safety issues

Air India Stenghting its Approach Towards Safety

The report further added that Air India has also become one of the 20 signatories of IATA's Safety Leadership Charter. The charter has been developed in consultation with IATA members, and the wider aviation community, to support industry executives in evolving a positive safety culture within their organizations.

Furthermore, Air India’s participation in IATA’s Safety Leadership Charter exemplifies the airline’s dedication to fostering a culture of safety. The charter aims to encourage industry leaders to create an environment that prioritizes safety above all else. It is a recognition of the importance of developing a positive safety culture within an organization, where safety is not just a set of rules and procedures but a fundamental aspect of the company’s DNA.

Mark Searle, IATA’s Global Director of Safety, highlights the need for audit programs to evolve in parallel with advancements in the aviation industry. These advancements include new technologies and practices that can enhance safety. Sticking to conventional compliance-based assessments can be limiting in this dynamic environment. Therefore, embracing a risk-based approach is essential for staying at the forefront of safety measures and ensuring that aviation remains one of the safest modes of transportation.

Eduard Ciofu, Flight Standards Deputy Director at the European Union Aviation Safety Agency, notes that transitioning to a risk-based approach will not be without its challenges. This approach will require oversight methodologies to adapt to the new paradigm, which will necessitate collaboration between airlines, regulators, and industry organizations. However, the benefits are substantial, as the industry can identify and mitigate risks more effectively, ultimately enhancing aviation safety on a global scale.

(With Inputs from The Economic Times)

Read next

Southwest Airlines Expands its 737 MAX Fleet with 108 B737-7 Orders

Abhishek Nayar

28 Oct 2023

In a significant move that reaffirms its commitment to the Boeing 737 MAX series, Southwest Airlines has placed a firm order for an additional 108 B737-7 aircraft. This substantial order cements Southwest's position as a major operator of the forthcoming B737 MAX variant. The airline's decision to expand its fleet underscores the continued confidence in Boeing's aircraft, despite the challenges faced by the MAX series in recent years.

The Southwest-Southwest Connection

Southwest Airlines, often referred to as an LCC (Low-Cost Carrier), has long been associated with the Boeing 737 series. This latest order adds to their already substantial fleet of Boeing 737s, and it comes as part of their strategy to modernize and upgrade their aircraft inventory.

Details of the Order

The commitment to purchase 108 B737-7 aircraft enhances Southwest's existing order book for this particular variant to a staggering 300 aircraft. However, neither the airline nor the manufacturer has disclosed the specific delivery timeline for these new jets. The B737-7 is not expected to receive certification before mid-2024, which means Southwest's latest acquisition is looking toward the long-term future.

Other Customers for the B737-7

Apart from Southwest Airlines, there are only a handful of other confirmed customers for the B737-7. Allegiant Air (24[18 + 6 converted]), Luxair (4), Ruili Airlines (2), and SkyUp Airlines (2) are among the few that have placed orders for this aircraft, with relatively smaller orders compared to Southwest's commitment. Allegiant Air recently converted six of its B737-7 orders into B737-8-200s, showcasing the flexibility of the MAX series to meet the diverse needs of airlines.

Fleet Renewal Strategy

Southwest's fleet strategy involves replacing older aircraft with more fuel-efficient and environmentally friendly models. The new B737-7s will gradually replace the airline's aging fleet of 406 B737-700s, which have been workhorses for the airline for many years.

Simultaneously, Southwest is in the process of introducing the larger B737-8s to replace its 207 B737-800s. This strategic transition allows Southwest to benefit from the flexibility of its Boeing order book, ensuring that the airline can maintain a modern and efficient fleet while awaiting the certification of the B737-7.

Conclusion

Southwest Airlines' order of 108 B737-7 aircraft not only solidifies its position as a dominant future operator of the B737 MAX series but also demonstrates the airline's confidence in Boeing's ability to deliver on its promises. As the aviation industry continues to evolve, Southwest is taking strategic steps to renew and expand its fleet, ultimately ensuring that it remains at the forefront of the industry. With the B737-7s on the horizon, Southwest is poised to maintain its reputation as a leading low-cost carrier with a commitment to safety, efficiency, and passenger satisfaction.

With Inputs from ch-aviation

Comment